A Perfect Circle OR Tool?

Please note: this is not a "bashing" thread or anything of the sort.
I am a fan of both great bands but personally prefer Tool. On some other fansite boards I go on, fans of both seem to prefer APC more (I found this slightly peculiar) So I just wanted to ask Tool and APC FANS on this board to share their opinion...
If you like neither bands, don't bother posting "they both bite" or anything of that intellect.

I think Tool are far superior musically and Maynard's lyrics are about more meaningful things in general and to me, in Tool.

I really love Mer De Noms and Thirteenth Step though, two of my fav albums.

-AC

You're going to make me choose between the two? cry

I like Tool better, but it's veeeeeeeeeeeeeeeery close.

I HAVE been listening to APC nonstop for the past two weeks though. Dunno why but I'm currently obsessed with them.

TOOL. Dunno why, but I don't get caught up in APC's songs as well as I do in Tool songs.

I like them both, and I really can't say thats whats best because they are so different. Tool is harder and more intense, but the lyrics and feel or APC is more medatative and clamer.

Tool easily IMO.

I love both bands, but I would have to say Tool hands down.

Tool.

Tool 😛... but by like a tiny bit 😊

Tool, eMOTIVE brought APC down a notch in my book

wow tough choice .. TOOL .. since eMOTIVe kinda ... sucked 🙁 .. TOOL is up there again for me

They have the same singer, and that's pretty much all they have in common. I hate it when people compare the two.

But yeah, Tool all the way 🥷

Emotive is an album of covers. it was expected to suck. Tool all the way

Stupid Question,

Tool easily.

Not even remotely close. As great as APC are, the only thing keeping them within driving distance is having the same frontman.

Can someone recommend some APC songs for me to listen to?

The Noose, The Hollow, Judith, Rose, Sleeping Beauty, 3 Libras, Orestes, The Outsider, Gravity, Weak and Powerless, Blue, Passive.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
The Noose, The Hollow, Judith, Rose, Sleeping Beauty, 3 Libras, Orestes, The Outsider, Gravity, Weak and Powerless, Blue, Passive.

-AC

✅

Though I'd add Magdalena, The Package, and Pet.

Pretty much just get the albums.

-AC

Agreed.