Okay, voting should be done by now. Girls:5 Guys:2. To Scoobless and Pr: I am sorry that it had to come to this, but I could not decide because I felt that my judgement would be biased. Anyways, in the future, I will try to make rules clearer, and I am more than sure, that you will give the guys the great arguements that will help them succeed in future missions.
Originally posted by laydiiplayette
Okay, voting should be done by now. Girls:5 Guys:2.
you do understand that you just made this entire thread a waste of time?
with 5 people coming into this to specifically argue one side they are obviously going to vote for that side, against two arguing and voting for the other...... you may as well conclude the rest of the battles right now by saying that more people are on the girls side therefore the girls will always win in the vote
Originally posted by laydiiplayette
Not all battles are going to end in votes. The previous 2 did not end in votes, and the next one may or may not.
regardless of previous or future battles, this one did conclude with a vote and with only two people on the male side we could have been arguing Superman versus Jubilee and still been outvoted........ you must understand what i am saying
no i'm a male and i voted female, galactic is a male and he voted female. sex doesn't matter what matters is who you believe can win. this thread ended in votes because it was too close, there was a way that the girls can win, and there was a way guys can win- it was even and if lady had said girls wwill win then you would call her unfair because she is a women and if she said guys then people can say that she can make whoever wants to win cause the's the boss. it was logicall to say votes and its no ones fault that only two people voted for the guys and its no ones fault that five people voted for the girls
Originally posted by Scoobless
regardless of previous or future battles, this one did conclude with a vote and with only two people on the male side we could have been arguing Superman versus Jubilee and still been outvoted........ you must understand what i am saying
I do. I do not see why you are singling out my thread. There are lots of other threads that have polls. Those are based on votes as well. What if there was some way for Jubilee to logically beat Superman (this is just an example, I do not really believe that Jubilee can beat Superman). There are so many people, that would just look at that poll and say "psh", then go and vote for Superman. I am saying that people vote on their opinions and views and isn't that what we came here for.
Originally posted by stormfront13
no i'm a male and i voted female, galactic is a male and he voted female. sex doesn't matter what matters is who you believe can win.
You don't seem to get what i'm saying........ i'll try again......
I'm not saying males will vote male and females will vote female..... you took the female side from the start, so did galactic
The point is that the females case was argued for by a larger number and when it comes time to vote we will all vote the side we argue for
Therefore the system of voting becomes pointless
You may as well count how many people are on each side before any argument is made and award the victory that way
It'd save a hell of a lot of time (and logic) in the long run
so what finnuaua never posted here then all of a sudden she appeared and voted women cause she liked who was on the team. more people argued for women cause they thought women could win. i think i get what ur saying but by doing voting we get an actual vote. ans can we please start voting whose going home??
Originally posted by laydiiplayette
I do. I do not see why you are singling out my thread. There are lots of other threads that have polls. Those are based on votes as well.
I'm singling out this one because of what it is, you went to a lot of trouble to organise a tournament, did the whole team selection thing, got through the first couple of battles and now it's in danger of crashing due to the decision process..... most of the other VOTE threads are one offs and have no effect on anything outwith their own single fight..... the outcomes of these fights affect the selectable characters for future rounds so i don't want people to waste their time participating and making solid cases, only to have it come down to "how many people decided to argue for each side" to be the deciding factor
Originally posted by stormfront13
so what finnuaua never posted here then all of a sudden she appeared and voted women cause she liked who was on the team.
you are making my point for me, Fionnuala made three posts..... this is the extent of them
Originally posted by Fionnuala
i vote for women...especialy Storm, Polaris and Phoenix 🥷
Originally posted by Fionnuala
and Polaris could do some pretty bad stuff to them 😉
Originally posted by Fionnuala
okay...sorry 😮..i should really read the thread properly
she obviously "voted" without having any idea what was going on or what arguments had been made........ showed up .......said she votes for women........ makes herself seem foolish............ then leaves........ no arguments, no scenarios, no references and no logic........ why even bother going through the debate part of it if that's how you want this tournament to work?