I'm guessing Maul, since one Obi-Wan was only a young padawan while the other was an old man who barely used his powers for some 20 years. One Obi-Wan hasn't reached his peak yet, while the other Obi-Wan is far past his peak.
DAR
Darth_NefarusRedi Knight
Old Obi-Wan's lightsaber would short circuit, then young Obi-Wan would fall down a hole from a force push... you see where I'm going with this.
ART
ArthasKnightDark Lord of the Sith
Well, Padawan Obi-Wan did manage to defeat Maul on his own but not before Qui-Gon was killed. I believe that Ben Kenobi would only slow Padawan Kenobi down and lead to a Darth Maul victory.
BAR
Bardock42Junior Member
It think the kernobis take that...easily. I think Ben is much stronger than Qui Gon was and the padawan killefd maul himself well with some luck of course
ART
ArthasKnightDark Lord of the Sith
Ben Kenobi stronger than Qui-Gon?! No way! Qui-Gon is much stronger than old, frail Ben Kenobi.
BAR
Bardock42Junior Member
Well if you think so your problem, just well its not tre, Obi Wan got much stronger than Qui Gon ever was, well I belive so at least. He might have even killed Vader (well very unlikely but still)
DAR
Darth_NefarusRedi Knight
I would say old Obi-Wan has the edge on the Qui-Gonn we saw. Obi-Wan purposely lost and became one with the force. If Maul wouldn't have gotten a little pep talk from Sidious "They will be no match for you" he would have finished Obi-Wan off instead of taunting.
JAC
jackstainRestricted
Maul would win, and why dont you think of it this way, ben kenobi, vs qui gon......qui gon would break his hip....then cut off his head.
JUL
JulieThe Student
uh okay....young obi wan killed Maul....so er I'd expect this to end the same way
JAC
jackstainRestricted
no logic in that statement ^^
ART
ArthasKnightDark Lord of the Sith
^^No logic in that statement, Julie made perfect sense. Obi-Wan beat Maul in Epidode 1, so it's to be expected that this battle ends with the same result.