Haldir's Death

stop mocking the death scene!

well he got a scimitar down the back he was going to die anyway so why bother about behind you

I mock neither his death nor the death scene. And it was not a scimitar but an Uruk-Hai sword. His first wound was not fatal, painful but not fatal.

an urak sword is a scimitar.

and stop trying to correct everyone it's pissing me off.

Having a contradictory point of view is not correcting anyone. If you feel that way then in all probability your information is incorrect. A scimitar an elegantly curved sword whereas an Uruk sword is not. No where does it say in the book or in the movie that the swords were labeled thus.

no you are trying to correct everyone and it's pissing people off just accept it.

Thor out

The point of this thread was to disseminate information that may be of interest to everyone. Whether one persons' points differ from another on Haldir's death shouldn't be a cause for someone to be angry. If you and others feel angry at my point then I do not apologize for having my points differ from yours. Showing anger is showing a lack of understanding or knowledge.

no it's not your point im dissagreeing with it's valid it's the fact that you are commenting on little things in other peoples posts that matter not.

well yah know Thor...the guy is after all...*gets cut off*

😂^^

na Thor man you should take an easy, but I do think the guy is trying to show of the knowledge a little too quickly

I like knowledgable types on this here forum 😄

Originally posted by Discos
😂^^ I like knowledgable types on this here forum 😄

Hmm does that count u out mate? 😛

i just think that scene is sad ... 🙁 not sad as in cheesy but crying sad ... and no i didn't cry at it

i was well p'ed off when i seen him die lol i quite liked Haldir in the books, but it was a very good scene and i wouldn't take it out, even if it isn't in the books.

i thought the scene was done really well to ..

Originally posted by Morningstar
Hmm does that count u out mate? 😛

Discos - blech

you opened yourself up for that discos 😛

mech I dont need to argue how my knowledge vastly exceeds a fair number of people on this forum.

I dont brag about it, but throw in my 2-cent every "now and again" 😛

Originally posted by Discos
mech I dont need to argue how my knowledge vastly exceeds a fair number of people on this forum.

I dont brag about it, but throw in my 2-cent every "now and again" 😛

😆

"am so smart.....so smarter than you....Hibert" - comic book guy

anyways, Haldirs death sounded better in the books,

Originally posted by Discos
anyways, Haldirs death sounded better in the books,

😬

It definitely did
Because it didn't exist in the book ... and anything is better than Haldir's death 🙄