Originally posted by who?-kid
Wrong
[B]
Wrong
[B]
True
[B]
Wrong
You disagree, but you haven't given any reasons why. Do you have any?
Spiderman is clearly outclassed in just about every way. Rogue has greater strength, speed, and durability, that is "comic fact". Plus with one touch he's out cold. Spidey is dead meat.
Well...in one Claremont story, Rogue grabbed bullets out from the air (like 50 or so)...but this was the same story that introduced and blue-goth-ponytail-slavetrading-crimelord-smurf, and I am still angry to Claremont for creating the eighth sin, so I will call that bad writing.
IMO, it can go both ways.
Spiderman has beaten the crap out of people a lot stronger than Rogue.
She can fly fast. That's it. His reflexes and agility are way
the hell too much for her. Plus his spidersense. And he's clothed from
head-to-toe. What the hell is she gonna do??? Spiderman can dodge
her all day long. One web-shot to the eyes and many punches later,
he'll deliver her to the mansion with a note from "your friendly neighborhood Spiderman."
Originally posted by Zahit
Spiderman has beaten the crap out of people a lot stronger than Rogue.
She can fly fast. That's it. His reflexes and agility are way
the hell too much for her. Plus his spidersense. And he's clothed from
head-to-toe. What the hell is she gonna do??? Spiderman can dodge
her all day long. One web-shot to the eyes and many punches later,
he'll deliver her to the mansion with a note from "your friendly neighborhood Spiderman."
Rogue has beaten the crap out of people a lot stronger than spiderman. She can move a lot faster than he can and her reflexes are also heightened. She's also got a sixth sense similar to the spidersense.
Who cares if he's fully clothed, Spidey's not wearing impregnable armor. She'll pull that mask off and cram it down his throat.
Originally posted by sbo
Rogue has beaten the crap out of people a lot stronger than spiderman. She can move a lot faster than he can and her reflexes are also heightened. She's also got a sixth sense similar to the spidersense.
Who cares if he's fully clothed, Spidey's not wearing impregnable armor. She'll pull that mask off and cram it down his throat.
are you telling me rogue has faster reflexes, can move, act, react,
faster than spiderman?
Originally posted by sbo
I read it all, I should have said do you have any VALID reasons. The reasons you gave earlier don't hold up when you look at Rogue's abilities.
Rogue: is stronger, can fly, has absorbing powers, has a certain degree of invulnerability (though is by no means "invulnerable"😉
Spider-Man: is faster, more experienced (especially in solo fights), has very strong webbing, has pre-cognitive danger sense, can stick to any surface, has greater agility and flexability
most people who know the characters will accept this as a fair rendition of each characters ability in comparison with the other
flight speed wont make a difference, Nova (bucket head Nova) has much faster flight speed than Rogue and couldn't make contact with Spidey
the only real advantages Rogue has is her strength and durability (absorbing doesn't help if she can't make contact AND remove some of his costume), but neither matter if she can't land a hit, Spider-Man on the other hand has used his powers to beat down people with all of Rogues advantages before ie: Iron Man 2020 and Superboy (i know i'll get a response to that)
Spidey will win almost all of the encounters between these two
long fight, very long, but Spidey pulls it out. The strength issue here cancel each other out, except endurance would go to spiderman. Spideys webbing is only usefull for biding time, which is advantageous. Rogues flight takes spidey's reflexes down a notch, because if she were smart at all, she would force spidey to come to her. However, i see Rogue on the offensive which does mean that spidey relflex counts for somthing, untill rogue absorbs spidey's spider sense, which cancels each other out. The only thing that wins this match is spidermans tactics, and ability to change his strategy on a whim
Originally posted by sbo
I'm sure spidey's reflexes are faster, but they wouldn't be fast enough. Rogue's caught bullets fired at her from an automatic weapon, so I think her reflexes are more than adequate. She could definitely land a hit on spiderman, and then it's all over.
Her reflexes are quick, no doubt there.however, Agility is on spidermans side, but again after absorbing spider sense, it doesnt matter at all. Spiderman dodges bullets, so i dont exactly see where the point of rogue catching bullets is. Spidey can definently take a head on punch from Rogue, i wouldnt say many, but a few. Rogues challenge is hitting him, which is very possible.