why do we all believe so much in episode II?

I dunno. He's younger than in the OT, so he may look a bit more energetic.

And with all the fighting he has to do, a flying puppet would look ridiculous..... but my fear is that a fighting and leaping Yoda will look ridiculous anyway...

Only 25 more days for most to wait ...then the judment can be passed on the question of CGI Yoda..vs. Puppet Yoda
BTW I believe answer one to the question should cover just about everything 🙂

no! I hate it! it's a stupid movie! 😄

Hang on!!!

I like the CGI Yoda better, the puppet Yoda reminded me of the Muppets, it wasn't unique to Star Wars.

You are talking about CGI Yodas in ALL of the films? So GL is going ahead with the "Definitive Editions" then?

Originally posted by DJ Velocity
So GL is going ahead with the "Definitive Editions" then?

It could happen...In about 10 yrs there'll probably be a new Dvd collection of the entire Star Wars Saga

I hope he doesn't add or change too much in the original films.

There's a rumor that GL filmed some stuff for ANH. Like Jimmy Smits character on Aldeeran before it blows up or something.

I hope not! Don't touch the OT!

I agree, he shouldn't change anything.

That's been said before, but the Special Editions were well received. Remember, no film is ever finished, only abandoned.

when I watch the OT I want to watch the great original star wars movies, not redone, ''new'' films.

Even if GL thinks that new versions would better reflect his vision of what they should be like?

difficult question... one thing I DON'T want him to do is polish the special-effects.

Persoanlly I would kill to see him re-do the Rancor scene.

don't know...it looks crappy but that's how it was and should be, it wouldn't feel right re-done. I certainly don't like the computer generated stuff in the special editions.

Hmm, oh well. I love it, and GL is certainly happier with it.

I would only hope that George Lucas wouldn't screw up the OT by putting Jar Jar Binks or some other horrible character in there.

Well, he's created a ton more aliens in the PT, so he's most likely to add a Gungan in there somewhere.

I agree with Queeq's theory on the CGI Yoda. It would look ridiculous with a flying puppet. They launch him on a catapult and he go "Flying I am, hm hm!"

Originally posted by Ushgarak
Persoanlly I would kill to see him re-do the Rancor scene.

Originally posted by ToMacco
I'm a little pissed about the CGI Yoda. He looks like Jar Jar. 🙁

After TPM, I wouldn't trust Lucas to make a great movie with ANY script, even the one from ANH. He would screw it up with some idiotic CGI character like Jar Jar and generally direct it in an incompetent manner like he did with TPM.