Exar Kun and Darth Sidious vs. Anakin and Luke Skywalker

Originally posted by Nai Fohl
I'm slightly confused by the overall setting.

a) Anakin is at full potential, right ?
b) Luke is ANH Luke but trained from infancy ? Or is it NJO Luke but trained from infancy on ?
c) Sidious in his prime ? That would be DE Sidious, right ?

Now well...

If its ANH Luke trained from infancy on + full potential Anakin, and DE Sidious, Sidious would destroy Luke and then help Kun with killing Anakin.

If its NJO Luke with training from infancy on + full potential Anakin, and DE Sidious - Anakin would take Kun and then help Luke with Sidious.

If you actualy thought of ROTS Sidious being Sidious at his peak than it doesn't matter which Luke you take. NJO version and ANH version with training from infancy on would kill ROTS Sidious.

So well...although I'm slightly confused I would say Jedi win...

I am also confused by the same aspects of the fight - is it NJO Luke, trained from infancy? In that case, Luke would be much more powerful than Darth Sidious and, though Exar Kun is doubtless one of the most powerful Sith of all time, but versus a full-potential Anakin, I'm not sure anyone could win (though such a phenomenon can only be speculated, so this is completely subjective). Throwing powered-up NJO Luke into the fray, I think that Kun would perish. Thus, given the specifications I have made based on interpretation, I also think that the Jedi would win.

If the chosen one prophecy means anything I say full potential anakin and trained from birth luke would win.

This thread confuses me...but all go with the Jedi.

i agree with vengence if the prophecy means anything and luke take on the other 2 they win not easily it'd be a challenge but they'd end up winning.

Prophecy does NOT apply in the versus threads. It's a vaguely outlined, never verified plot element that basically means nothing in the grand scheme of things. And this thread, looking back, should have been dismissed as ridiculous. Why? Well, I could just as easily make a thread saying Exar Kun (assuming he never ever died but lived for 140 years and studied Sith lore that whole time and killed and ate Ragnos's spirit, blah blah) and Yoda (assuming he was a Sith training from infantcy and studying Sith lore for nine hundred years, blah blah) versus Anakin (will full über power as a fifty year old jedi master with amazing Force potential and power) and Luke (Who is the regular NJO suckass.)

See how damn ridiculous that is? Why not just speculate and say that it's raining lava while they fight?

Originally posted by DarthGenises
Do it.

Got msn or yahoo so i can send it you?
my yahoo is:
[email protected]
msn is:
[email protected]
🙂

how much time did Anakin train Luke?

omfg... You people, I swear.

what did i say? im just asking a question

lol... I'm teasing. Relax. If you see me type "omfg" I am obviously either possessed by the spirits of n00bism or I am just playing around.

LUKE PWN3DS!!!!!

The sith wins this fight.

Originally posted by Darth Windu
LUKE PWN3DS!!!!!

lmfao!

Originally posted by Darth_Janus
lmfao!

Luke dose pwnds expecily his "green spark" force power which apparntly is a green chain force lighting that kills on impact
and is offen descired as "the maleforcestorm"