Poll
27%
55%
18%
I voted Visas, because that made most sence to me at first, but now that i'm trying to think of why i keep coming up with reasons Bastila would win.
So hm sorry for that vote, Bastila would probably win... and not because of battle meditation, how the hell could she start using battle meditation in a fight between her and somebody else? Sitting on the ground and meditating then would not really help her
Of course not, but Bastila went through a lot too. She did fight a lot and probably more then Visas did, not to mention that Visas was the apprentice of Nihilus because she could see threw the force better then anybody else, not because of her mad skills with a lightsaber, in fact when Nihilus picked her up she wasn't even a real force user yet.
Nihilus trained her and did it fast and made her powerful, but she did not have the training or experience Bastila has. The fight probably wouldn't be easy, but i'd be higly surprised if Bastila didn't come out on top.
I think if Visas was fighting Bastila for a certain reason, say, because her master or even the exile wanted her to, she would have more convinction. The only time Bastila should proper convinction that led me to believe she would win a fight was when she tried to protect Revan. And she lost that one, through no fault of her own.
But I always look at battles as a test of wills as well as a test of abilities. I mean, Bastila was easily captured by thugs in Taris. Visas seems much more capable than that.
Bastila was weak and unexperienced then... Besides she lost her lightsaber...
God that hardly improves the situation 😛
Still i think Bastila came a long way since then, its no biggie that she couldn't stand up against Malak what did you expect? But Bastila could be very commited to a situation and put her life on the line for an ideal a thought a dream or a person. Visas would do the same and she is no pushover... But Bastila imo has just more experience and better training.
Would both have been trained the same time by the same masters then Visas would beat Bastila, but they weren't. Visas has not been able to use the force as long as Bastila. And seeing as Bastila had been training since her childhood and Visas only a few years after the Star Forge, Bastila would just be able to defeat her.