Ummm

you know how harry can see the horse things that you only see when you WATCHED sum1 get killed

well

he didnt watch Cedric get murdered he had his eyes closed and wouldnt he be able to see them before that because he saw his mom croak over

I was wondering about that too.. He should have seen the horses from the beginning because he might have witnessed his mum died. Hmm... that leads me to the question, "is Lily alive?"

???
i really dont think that

i do

well, they can only see the horses if they accept that the person they saw is actually dead. watching someone die is a traumatic thing, so it'll take a bit of time to fully swallow it.

Originally posted by brandon webb
lily is hot (r we talkin bout harry) i no a person with a ghetto horse (we talkin bout umbridge?) i luv hufflepuff
do i post here if i think gandalf would kick he-who-must-not-be-named's bottom?

yea 😆

well harrys dad kept the door, from voldy...so harry couldnt have seen him

theres lots of rumour about lily being a death eater at one point....maybe she is alive, but then, how did harry survive.......and why would sirius have felt so bad

but if harrys not the dude who lived

who is

mr. longbottom??

thats all stupid
i dont think so cos HP is main char!

Hey, i never thought that lily might still be alive. Thats a good idea.
Thats got me thinking now. 😕