Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I think the Jedi win. Luke could kill any of them by himself Mace could definately hold Maul back long enough for Luke to help, Kyle would suck though. Light Triumps.
Kyle definitely would not suck. he might even be the most skilled WITHOUT a saber or Force. Considering that he was trained at a later age after he was already a soldier/mercenary...
Well, Sith have my vote. Maul's a magrick ningra Sith who's played by a bloody martial arts expert. Vader is hella tall and powerful and hard to punch in that suit. Revan was most likely capable in melee combat since ancient Jedi apparently trained in both armed and unarmed melee combat. (Note that Bastila and Revan sparred with vibroblades, and also that Jedi receive unarmed combat feats that only soldier classes get).
And while Kyle wouldn't be a push-over and Mace could probably stomp a little bit, Luke is the weakest link. Kickin' ass ain't like dustin' crops, kid.