Maul vs AotC Anakin

Started by vader112 pages
Originally posted by Janus Marius
Maul wins.

Originally posted by DarthRB
Maul wins.As of AotC,Anakin is too hot-headed,and that's why he got his arm chopped off-he did not THINK about the consequences of the charge.
Nice of you to bump a two year old thread only to agree with other people's ancient posts..

Well, but it is the truth.Lets face it,Maul COULD have defeated Qui-Gon and Kenobi,but he underestimated the boy.He got cut in half ONLY because he did not kill Kenobi when he had the chance(When Kenobi was hanging by the pit.)Maul could have killed him at this point,but he let hes arrogance get the better of him and thats when Kenobi cut him in half.As for Skywalker,when the fight with Dooku started he charged stupidly and ignoring teamwork at Dooku,and was beaten.Then,after,when Kenobi threw his light saber to Anakin,he just did the same thing,and lost again.This isn't being hot-headed? Maul actually used his head at his fight,if he had done the same thing as Anakin,he would get killed earlier in the fight, maybe when Kenobi went all Dark Side on him,or by Qui-Gon.Remember that Maul wasn't at full strengh at this fight.

Maul with some difficulty. Anakin isn't strong enough yet.

Maul wins easily

Originally posted by overlord
Nice of you to bump a two year old thread only to agree with other people's ancient posts..

What's worse is this one is 10 years old.

I believe Gillard called TPM Maul an 8 and somewhere else when talking about Kenobi and Skywalker in ROTS, said they were both 7's in AOTC before going up to an 8 and a 9.