Darth Revan vs. NJO Luke

All hell is gonna break loose! Who's the last one standing?

probably NJO luke still i voted Revan cuz i didn't wanna see him loose bad

You say that like there will be -anything- left stand, dude...

Well, I think Revan would lose the battle, but I don't think Luke would kill him, he would do his best to try and turn him.
Then Revan would likely run off and convert some of Luke's students, causing an even larger battle

And the Vong would suddenly seem small time.

Luke.

I like the idea of Luke (being he invincible little $!!$ he is) defeating Revan and turning him. Then Revan could be in charge of the New Republic fleet and defeat the Vong. Nice ehh!

Just to shake things up a bit, I'm gonna post a bunch of reasons for Revan's amazing power.

Revan was always powerful. Even as a padawan, his teachers were sure that he would become a champion of the Force. His master Kreia said "Revan was power. Staring into his eyes was like staring into the heart of the Force.” Revan had a lust for knowledge, seeking out every piece of information he could about the Jedi.

Later, Revan discovered an ancient, planet-sized Sith storehouse of knowledge (Malachor V). Only Revan’s immensely strong will kept him from immediately falling to the dark side. Revan plundered these tombs and relics, learning of the location and true nature of Korriban. He learned of the location of other Sith artifacts, and he learned how those strong in the light side of the Force could be seduced and made to see the strength inherent in the Sith teachings. Malachor V fueled Revan’s tremendous dark side power, making him even stronger. Revan was a brilliant military strategist, and 1/3 of the Republic’s army was under Revan’s direct command. It was only because of him that the Republic defeated the Mandalorians. Somewhere around this time, Revan killed Mandalore and Yusanis, the most famous Echani warrior (and the handmaiden’s father.)

Revan then located the Star Forge and was powerful enough to control it without being consumed. Revan soon turned on the Republic and nearly conquered the galaxy. Countless Jedi knights fell in battle and many more swore allegiance to the new Dark Lord of the Sith. For two years the Sith were all but invincible. Only Bastila’s Battle meditation kept the Sith from total triumph.

Darth Revan then lost his memories and his connection to the Force when Darth Malak betrayed him and fired upon his ship. 1 year later, with relatively little Jedi training, Revan returned to Korriban and plundered the tombs of Marka Ragnos, Ajunta Pall, Tulak Hord, and Naga Sadow, gaining new Sith artifacts and fueling his new power even further. Revan even destroyed Ajunta Pall’s spirit.

Upon (if) returning to the dark side, Revan traveled to the Star Forge, fighting his way through dozens of dark Jedi to find his ex-apprentice Darth Malak. At this point, Revan’s power was even greater than when he was the Dark Lord of the Sith during his first reign. Malak didn’t even think it was possible for him to have gotten stronger since his first reign, but he was. Revan then killed Malak and retook control of the Star Forge, wiping out the Republic and nearly exterminating the last of the Jedi.

Soon after, Revan recovered his memories and all the knowledge he plundered while on Malachor V, enhancing his power even further. Darth Revan returned to Malachor V before heading into the unknown regions to fight the ancient Sith species. Charismatic and powerful, we still have yet to see Darth Revan’s full abilities since he was never defeated.

ah come on, does everyone think Darth Revan would win or what?

No, Luke has mastered the force in ways no one else has.

how, he trained himself

He didn't train himself, he had Jedi Knight Lights like Obi-Wan and Yoda and Anakin to tell him bedtime stories

he was probably not trained in the more powerful, harder to use stuff because of a lack of time. It may be like traditional sword fightinh. He can stab but not much else.

And swing/hack like a mad-man. Case in point, his final duel with Vader.

Yes, but that was young Luke who had barely begun to discover his powers.
Once the force flows through a Skywalker, they're pretty hard to stop man

I don't know, but its going to be damn hard for somebody who although powerful has very little training against somebody who is also incredibly powerful with a lot of training.

Luke may have learned a lot sinse ROTJ, he always trained himself however. Meaning he could not have learned the ancient knowledge that Revan learned. He was powerful but he lacks knowledge and training.

Whatever the outcome however the universe would have some trouble recovering from that battle...

If Luke wasn't the lucky bugger he is then Revan would win hands down. But Lukes just unkillable.

There is no luck, there is only the force

Fine, the force makes Luke unkillable. Well, I mean, he could be killed and all, by naturakl causes. But the force has a lot invested in the Skywalker clan, thy're important for battling the forces of evil.

"there is no question, there is the grin on luke's terrible-acting face after he spanks revan via lightsaber"