Faith and Medicine: Where is the Line?

Started by Draco691 pages

Faith and Medicine: Where is the Line?

I've heard some stories of highly-religous people who have refused to give their children vaccines and/or medical treatments because their faith prohibits it. I remember one story where a seven year old boy died of pnemonia because their parents refused treatment. They thought that their child's fate was solely in God's hands and no human being should interfere with God's will. What do you guys think?

They are the dumbest people I have ever heard of.

They obviously don't love their child.

The main question is if the government should impose certain vaccines and medications if the parents decline to do so. However the freedom to religion may prohibit this. Where is the line?

The goverment should take the child away from his/her preants....isn't there an law for that?

Child negligence. However when faith gets involved the law gets fritzed.

*sigh* Yes...the unbearable law system...

I think thats insane..

If they think like that they should never take a step, for all they know it was gods will for him to be saved by those medicines, reminds me of a joke.

A guy was on a boat in the middle of the sea when a storm came and his boat sunk, he managed to survive. Lying there on the water he started praying for god to help him. Some time later a boat came by, the people there wanted to pick him up but he refused help. "God will save me, i do not need your help." He stayed there and the boat went away. He started praying again, for the winds to take him to shore. He prayed and prayed until a helicopter came by. "Grab the hook we will save you." "Leave me be, i do not need your help God will save me." he shouted back at the pilot and the helicopter went away. He started praying again. Some time later when he almost giving up hope another boat came by offering to pick him up. But once again he refused the help saying that god will save him. A few minutes later he drowned.

Being dead and all his soul went to heaven there he met god and he was pissed off. "I have served you my entire life, always went to church prayed lived my life by your laws and always did what you wanted, why did you not save me?" "what are you talking about? I gave you three chances, you are the idiot that turned them down."

Thats how i feel about it, if god exists and a chance for life gets offered to you, then you accept it. Stupid idiots

Hey, that was an good story.

I've heard some stories of highly-religous people who have refused to give their children vaccines and/or medical treatments because their faith prohibits it. I remember one story where a seven year old boy died of pnemonia because their parents refused treatment. They thought that their child's fate was solely in God's hands and no human being should interfere with God's will. What do you guys think?

"THAT "IS" THE LINE" those parents should be publically hanged. n in most countries there are no laws or APPLICABLE laws guarding the children rights.

In Finland, those parents would go in prison for 8-lifetime years.

I know in the US children are required to have certain vaccines in order to attend school.

Also, I'm fairly sure that another adult can take a child for medical treatment if they're acting in the child's best interests.

That's thing these parents don't send their children to school. They homeschool them. People sometimes underestimate the impact of faith on the law. Did you know you can refuse a DNA swab from the CSI if you say it goes against your religion?

most of the time, if the parents are that naive, they are likely to be uneducated. and some cultures do prohibit the help of modern medicine. there's somethings that we just would not fully understand. and religion is one of them. when people believe in something, it's hard to make them non-believers. it's tatooed in their minds. nobody can force them to undo it.

Originally posted by DarkCrawler
They are the dumbest people I have ever heard of.

They obviously don't love their child.

the last part is STUPID!!

they're simply parents with issues... one must know that they have to do all they can to save their kid...

And they didn't. They just layed him on a bed while he suffered for days.