r.o.t.s anakin vs darthmaul

Started by TheAnimal1 pages

r.o.t.s anakin vs darthmaul

take a pick and place a bet. hands down it's anakin.

Well, in ROTS Anakin, at one point, he was pretty powerless. So I say Maul beats post-Mustafar-hotbath Anakin easy

But we'll ignore that very specific part of RotS Anakin. 😄

Pre-Suit Darth Vader is fearsome. Using the Shien/Djem So form of lightsaber combat, he used powerful, sweeping cuts in an attempt to completely overwhelm his opponent. His form did, however, almost completely forego defense in favor of this hyped up offensive philosophy. His powers with the Force were extraordinary: Vader matches Obi-Wan Kenobi, a powerful Jedi Master, with a Force push. Though he doesn't overwhelm Kenobi, he still keeps the Jedi Master from overwhelming him and at Anakin's point of training and his time spent as a Knight, that's pretty damn awesome.

Darth Maul's favored form of lightsaber combat is mostly unknown. The movies never clarify a fighter's style, but for the most part, it's pretty easy to see. Maul, however, is the only movie character to use a double-bladed lightsaber and thus when it comes to him, it's a bit harder to see. Based on his use of acrobatics, I'm going to say he's an Ataru fighter, which uses a lot of Force-assisted movement in order to overwhelm an opponent by sheer speed and mobility and get at vital points. Maul's ability with the Force is questionable; he never really does much. But we'll assume that since he is a Dark Lord, he's powerful enough.

Based on all this alone... I'm not sure who'd win, really. Dammit. It's known that Vader could use his Shien/Djem So form with a great degree of speed, so I'll assume that Vader (this is PRE-SUIT, mind) could probably match Maul's speedy form and return it with overwhelming power.

I'll say Vader wins, but it won't be easy.

If this is just Anakin before his turn, however, I'd say Maul wins.

Anakin off course,in ROTS he is almost as strong as his later Darth Vader form.Though it won't be an easy win.

I haven't seen the movie though.In the Netherlands it premiered at may nineteenth.

Originally posted by Otaku_Sith
Anakin off course,in ROTS he is almost as strong as his later Darth Vader form.Though it won't be an easy win.

So i think he'll be as strong as Vader

Originally posted by Wanderer259
But we'll ignore that very specific part of RotS Anakin. 😄

Pre-Suit Darth Vader is fearsome. Using the Shien/Djem So form of lightsaber combat, he used powerful, sweeping cuts in an attempt to completely overwhelm his opponent. His form did, however, almost completely forego defense in favor of this hyped up offensive philosophy. His powers with the Force were extraordinary: Vader matches Obi-Wan Kenobi, a powerful Jedi Master, with a Force push. Though he doesn't overwhelm Kenobi, he still keeps the Jedi Master from overwhelming him and at Anakin's point of training and his time spent as a Knight, that's pretty damn awesome.

Darth Maul's favored form of lightsaber combat is mostly unknown. The movies never clarify a fighter's style, but for the most part, it's pretty easy to see. Maul, however, is the only movie character to use a double-bladed lightsaber and thus when it comes to him, it's a bit harder to see. Based on his use of acrobatics, I'm going to say he's an Ataru fighter, which uses a lot of Force-assisted movement in order to overwhelm an opponent by sheer speed and mobility and get at vital points. Maul's ability with the Force is questionable; he never really does much. But we'll assume that since he is a Dark Lord, he's powerful enough.

Based on all this alone... I'm not sure who'd win, really. Dammit. It's known that Vader could use his Shien/Djem So form with a great degree of speed, so I'll assume that Vader (this is PRE-SUIT, mind) could probably match Maul's speedy form and return it with overwhelming power.

I'll say Vader wins, but it won't be easy.

If this is just Anakin before his turn, however, I'd say Maul wins.

Maul uses form VII

it says Maul uses form VII on wizards.com

and an an issue of insider

ROTS Anakin.

form VII is vapaad and only Mace mastered vapaad

nice to have you back Kun-ni Habo.

Anyway, form VII was an ancient Jedi form made thousands of years earlier. Vapaad is simply an extension of form VII. Also, Mace's apprentice mastered Vapaad. Depa mastered is, she just wasn't very good compared to Mace. Just to let you know, mastering something doesnt mean being the best with it, it just means you know all of the form.

Originally posted by Kun-ni Habeo
form VII is vapaad and only Mace mastered vapaad

he is not the only practitioner. cappin'

Form VII is Juyo, and the completed, personal extension of it is Vaapad. So technically Maul is a practitioner of Juyo, although I didn't really see any evidence to support he even uses the style. It seems much more Ataru to me.

ROTS Anakin can waste all of the Sith we've seen in the movies.
Maul: gets owned.
Dooku: gets owned.
Sidious: gets owned

For his time (and argueably all time) he is the best and will waste anyone that he doesn't have a personal grudge against like Obi-Wan.

it says it in star wars insider issue #62 that maul uses form VII

it says "the form IV skills of obi wan and qui gon are little more than delaying against the form VII skills of darth maul."

or sumthing to that effect

2Glentract
thanx man still,,,don't expect me to be here too much cuz i have to finish this school year successful lol

Ok then. Maul uses Juyo, but not Vaapad. He could not have learned Vaapad without having been taught by Mace Windu, which of course did not happen.

maul dies