The Episode III Rotten Tomatoes Scale

Started by Batman3165 pages

Ohnoz.....

back to 90%

and the bubble bursts

That is just the review from IGN, you cant listen to a damn thing they say anyways.

How much do you guys want to bet that when the movie arrives to thetheaters the metter will drop down 40% or 30%?? remember i said it! it always happends before the premiere!

Originally posted by Batman316
Ohnoz.....

back to 90%

and the bubble bursts

Wait until Ebert puts down the Snickers bar and finishes his review. πŸ™

IGN's review brought them down, although they gave the movie 3/5.

I am looking forward to the Ebert review on tv this weekend, maybe get some new footage.

Originally posted by astrofan428
That is just the review from IGN, you cant listen to a damn thing they say anyways.

The moment I lost intrest in this guys opinion was when he tried to make some idiotic statement about Order 66 being not believable. Mainly stating that with all of the politics in the last 2 movies, it seemed stupid that all it took was a simple "kill everybody" order.

Then it was pretty apparent that this person saw the last 2 only once or twice, and forgot that "Clones are totally obediant, and take any order without question"

That makes it 3 bad reviews done by total morons

Originally posted by astrofan428
I am looking forward to the Ebert review on tv this weekend, maybe get some new footage.

Ooooohhh New footage.... drooldrooldrooliodroolio

How come IGN can reduce the points so much?!?!?!

U mean they have HIGHER weightage?

I dont understand how 3 out of 5 is bad, although there is not one positive thing in the review.

Originally posted by Lucas Sucks!
How much do you guys want to bet that when the movie arrives to thetheaters the metter will drop down 40% or 30%?? remember i said it! it always happends before the premiere!

ignored

its official
BUSH is a SITH LORD

Revenge of the Sith's two greatest moments tap into the uncertainty of our own political climate: the dazzling battle between Yoda and Darth Sidious (an outstanding Ian McDiarmid) inside the beautifully spiraling Senate hall evokes Democrats and Republicans scrambling for power and, during an obscenely over-the-top duel in Mustafar, Obi-Wan (Ewan McGregor) declares, "Only a Sith Lord deals in absolutes," after Anakin says, "If you're not with me, you're my enemy."
Ed Gonzalez

Republican movie critics (sigh)
they take offense when none is intended
just like a few patrons here.

Still 90% is pretty darn good.

Dude it looks like you guys cant get a different opinion, i think that the review was preety complete i have t see the movie if i think theyre right or not. I have always thought that order 66 or 69 was a very infantile way to make the clones look back and kill the jedi. There are more creative ways to do so. And brainwash is the lamest of them.

Originally posted by OB1-adobe
The moment I lost intrest in this guys opinion was when he tried to make some idiotic statement about Order 66 being not believable. Mainly stating that with all of the politics in the last 2 movies, it seemed stupid that all it took was a simple "kill everybody" order.

Then it was pretty apparent that this person saw the last 2 only once or twice, and forgot that "Clones are totally obediant, and take any order without question"

That makes it 3 bad reviews done by total morons

Originally posted by Lucas Sucks!
Dude it looks like you guys cant get a different opinion, i think that the review was preety complete i have t see the movie if i think theyre right or not. I have always thought that order 66 or 69 was a very infantile way to make the clones look back and kill the jedi. There are more creative ways to do so. And brainwash is the lamest of them.

ignored

Damn, down to 86%.

Originally posted by OB1-adobe
The moment I lost intrest in this guys opinion was when he tried to make some idiotic statement about Order 66 being not believable. Mainly stating that with all of the politics in the last 2 movies, it seemed stupid that all it took was a simple "kill everybody" order.

Then it was pretty apparent that this person saw the last 2 only once or twice, and forgot that "Clones are totally obediant, and take any order without question"

That makes it 3 bad reviews done by total morons

Nice point... I forgot about that πŸ˜‰

Who decides if these reviews are rotten or fresh anyway?

Not all the rotten ones seem rotten.

One of the critics thinks that Lucas' colouring is "gratuitously (offensive)" The critics favourite actor is Ian McDiarmid this time so we'll have to see.

You are soooo opened to critics, get a little of real judgement

Originally posted by bILLYgOAT
ignored