Do you agree with this article?

Started by WindDancer2 pagesPoll

News Article

Do you agree with this article?

http://msnbc.msn.com/id/7803983/

What do you guys think? Will Episode III answer all this questions?

Not all of them.

Anakin's ambitions will be though.

We need an I dont care option cause...well...I dont care, Imma love it anyway. 😂

I dont think many of them will be answered 🙁

Originally posted by smoker4
I dont think many of them will be answered 🙁

thats every true ^^^^

most of his questions come from fundamental misunderstandings of the movies...liek the whol Queen Naboo thing....The Quen is in change of the planet, the Senator is the diplomat to the Republic. The Senator can infer the wishes of the Republic to the Queen and can represent her, but the senator is not in control of the planet. Simple. Just like countries and the UN, although the UN is not a strong politically as the Republic.

I do think that #2 will most likely be answer. And I kinda agree with the "The timeline of the twins' birth, separation and concealment is essential." comment.

Originally posted by WindDancer
I do think that #2 will most likely be answer. And I kinda agree with the "The timeline of the twins' birth, separation and concealment is essential." comment.

I know what you mean.

I think that some/most of these questions will be answered

Not according to the novel 😮‍💨

Well, I read about this far:

1) Leia. Yes, she kicked butt, but you get the sense George Lucas never quite knew what he wanted to do with her.

... and realised this was a diabolically ignorant article, mercifully untouched by the ravages of the facts.

The Princess originally had a far larger role in early drafts of the script.
At one stage, she was described as "a beautiful young girl of 16, with untapped psychic powers of Godess-like force."
In fact, at the end of that particular treatment, she revealled herself to, literally, be a "goddess" during the end ceremony, leaving the band of "teenage rebels" realising that they had been "adventuring with demigods."

The sad fact is, Lucas was far to trusting of the opinions of his friends and mentors.
Francis Ford Coppola almost convinced Lucas to reduce Leia's role to mere sexual interest, while, at one stage, Lucas dropped the Princess altogether after feedback to his early drafts.
Ultimately, the importance of the Princess was reduced with each script revision.

So to suggest that Lucas simply didn't know what to do with her is short-sighted - at one point she was the focus of the entire script.

I'm with our very own Princess there - bring on the "I don't care" option...

🙂

OK, Fine!!!
😛

But, since you ask - IMO, everything will be answered...

Unless you are actively looking for problems.
Look for something hard enough, and you will see it.

1) That's just dumb, for the reasons given above.
2) Above the first Death Star.
3) The shroud of the Dark Side has fallen. Evil is everywhere, as the opening crawl states.
4) Vader's intentions are revealled in ROTS, along with why they are put on ice for 20 years.
5) The trials are explained in ROTJ - they are personal goals.
6) The Council does not know Jedi can turn bad. They still attribute Jedi sensibilities to Dooku - that is made clear in AOTC.
7) Yoda - "My failure, this was." The Jedi have a new agenda after ROTS thanks to QGJ.
8) See above.
9) We know all we need to know about Yoda. This is the fall and rise of Anakin Skywalker, not Yoda's Excellent Adventure.
10) It is an energy filed created by all living things. That'll do for me.

hmmmm.

I agree with some points, disagree with others. It is pretty obvious the author of this article has not read the novel, though.

Vader finds out about Luke in ANH when he is about to shoot him, The Force is strong with this one.
Then he is going to use luke to overthrow the emperor so Vader can be incharge, he just plays stupid when the emperor questions him in ESB cause he is already looking for him at the begining of ESB as the scroll indicates

Originally posted by mossman
But, since you ask - IMO, everything will be answered...

Unless you are actively looking for problems.
Look for something hard enough, and you will see it.

1) That's just dumb, for the reasons given above.
2) Above the first Death Star.
3) The shroud of the Dark Side has fallen. Evil is everywhere, as the opening crawl states.
4) Vader's intentions are revealled in ROTS, along with why they are put on ice for 20 years.
5) The trials are explained in ROTJ - they are personal goals.
6) The Council does not know Jedi can turn bad. They still attribute Jedi sensibilities to Dooku - that is made clear in AOTC.
7) Yoda - "My failure, this was." The Jedi have a new agenda after ROTS thanks to QGJ.
8) See above.
9) We know all we need to know about Yoda. This is the fall and rise of Anakin Skywalker, not Yoda's Excellent Adventure.
10) It is an energy filed created by all living things. That'll do for me.

I like your answers and the way you explain them. But don't you feel that #10 needs to be a little more detail? I've always have consider The force to be very important in the SW Universe. So important that it becomes a character itself. And just like any other SW character it deserves to have an origin and explanation....of course not trying to dig too deep into it.

Now see tho, doesnt analyzing the movie this much ruin it for you guys? Seriously? I just watch them for the "fun" and hell with all the plot holes etc etc.

And why do people keep calling me "princess"? 😕

We should call you Jade, that is Mara Jade in your Avatar right?

Originally posted by WindDancer
I like your answers and the way you explain them. But don't you feel that #10 needs to be a little more detail? I've always have consider The force to be very important in the SW Universe. So important that it becomes a character itself. And just like any other SW character it deserves to have an origin and explanation....of course not trying to dig too deep into it.

Hmm...
But how do you explain any faith?
Do you believe you have a soul, and if you do, could you explain what it is and where you keep it?

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess

And why do people keep calling me "princess"? 😕

I'm from the UK.
And you're a lady.
Alright, darlin'.
'Owdo, Princess.
Just a term of address...
😛
Okay, maybe we're just dyslexic...

Princess Leia is Stupid. She is the worst character ever created in filmes.

Yes, Jar-Jar is stupid too, but at least he's not human, so it makes some sense.

For a human to be as weird, and bizarre is Princess leia is just Wrong.

She's snobby, and arrogant, and stupid, and insulting, and as the daughter of Padme, and Anakin, George lucas will have to digitally put someone else in her place, and change her voice.

AHHHH, I scream, just imagining her saying "I don't know what your talking about" to vader at the beginning of ANH.

****, IS SO RETARDED.