<<But if hercules can lift planets, and he gets his ass smoked by hulk, Juggernaut etc,>>
eh? ass smoked by hulk?? only time that ever happened was when he was depowered. in the book from which i so proudly take my quote, herc was doing just fine, and in a much older book (i want to say tales to astonish but it don't think that was it) herc was getting the better of hulk. course, neither fight ended conclusively. they were close enough to say herc did not get smoked however. are dc's gods stronger/weaker than marvel's? can't really say. since i'm a marvel herc fan, i'll say he's the stronger version, hence he may be stronger than diana. c'mon, look at the quote!! hehe. and he didn't simply hold the 'earth' for atlas. he held the 'heavens' - that is all the sky (translated in places as the universe!) atlas is said to be the reason the sky doesn't fall. damn i love herc . . . .
i still say it will boil down to who's writing and what the situation is. in a given issue, any of the aforementioned guys could win against the other - and most HAVE. oh, and i'd add supreme (the original) to this list and perhaps at the top of it. he was beating glads pretty badly for much of that x-over.