Welling VS Routh (pic)

Bear in mind that this isn't Welling's body. Welling is more physically fit.
Have a look:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v649/masseysketch/WS.jpg

Save Superman!

we shouldn't even have a poll.... the answer is obviuos! 😠

welling is still too boyish imo...

These people never quit, 😂

Originally posted by CaptainAmerica
Bear in mind that this isn't Welling's body. Welling is more physically fit.
Have a look:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v649/masseysketch/WS.jpg

Save Superman!

Jeez man, give it a rest. Routh is gonna play him, and if it's sh8t then that's it. Neither of the two can replace Reeve. And both are boyish wannabes that try too hard.

~wickerman~

still you can't say because you have bad look you get the worst of two options you think are not the one you want.

Originally posted by Wickerman
Neither of the two can replace Reeve. And both are boyish wannabes that try too hard.

Exactly, very well said. ✅

it's not too late. Write the production company. Routh is a fruit.

Save Superman!

Originally posted by CaptainAmerica
it's not too late. Write the production company. Routh is a fruit.

Save Superman!

and welling is a boy...

Welling is 2 years older than Routh, and older than Reeve when he started Superman.

Yet he still looks 17 and at least 7 years younger than Reeve and Routh.

Routh looks like he's about to have a seizure and welling looks like he's always high on crack. But that won't change the fact that Routh's playing him and that Welling's not.

~wickerman~

I like the way you guys think, you're not satisfied with anything. I can't stand the sight of Routh, so it seems I must pick a side. Welling looks like a pretty good Superman.

Originally posted by pr1983
and welling is a boy...

despite i don't like what you say.... it's true, i was watching an episode from the first season, and he looked like a 14 year old kid, even if his face has mature a little bit, he still looks like a boy, not a man, but i think that's not the reason to scre# superman, they should've waited a couple of years, cause this routh doesn't look at all like superman, but welling would do a better superman in a fwe years. ✅

Of course it's Welling but we'll have to deal with Routh until we see Tom as Superman on Smallville.

Originally posted by alexanderluthor
they should've waited a couple of years, cause this routh doesn't look at all like superman, but welling would do a better superman in a fwe years. ✅

A few more years? He is already 27 years old, he isn't going to look more like Superman anytime soon, all you can wait for now is for him to gain wrinkles.

We need more people like you. There are so many heated Routh fanboys on this site it's hillarious.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0348150/board/threads/

Now your calling me a "Routh fanboy" because I know Welling would not be a decent Superman? Personally I don't like either actor as Superman and the only "fanboy" here is you.

Relax, the site I was referring to was the one I put up the link for.

neither is fit to be superman, whether compared to reeve or not...

and as much as i hate to say this, half the people who watch smallville have never bothered to read a superman comic or watch the old movies... and have no idea what the hell they are talking about...