Well after seeing the movie for the first time, I wish I watched less spoilers. Anyway the good and the bad.
Bad:
The acting from Padme just didn't seem that good to me.
The space battle was too short.
The battles were too cut up.
Zoomed lightsaber battles really bug me, you can't see what going on.
The fade in and out effects sucked at times.
Needs more footage from the temple.
Good:
Order 66 was just so emotional I almost cried.
The lightsaber fights were great.
Palps was great.
Overall I loved this movie, it gives me a entire new look on Vader.