Qui-Gon(spoilers)

Well I know that's what he's doing I am just commenting on what the look he gives would represent were we to see it in everyday life. Whatever it is supposed to mean, that is what the look is that he gives. It could be he is trying to tell Anakin he made him. It could be Ian McDiarmid make an acting blunder, it could have been Lucas made a directin blunder, whatever.

I think Lucas meant to leave that question unanswered, kind of like the Yoda origins question.

Yoda origins??? Amazing...

I doubt that Palpy made Anakin and that look is just the look of anticipation and endulgement: something like... I know Anakin likes to hear that.

Originally posted by queeq
Yoda origins??? Amazing...

I doubt that Palpy made Anakin and that look is just the look of anticipation and endulgement: something like... I know Anakin likes to hear that.

😕 I was under the impression that Lucas has forbidden the EU to discuss certain things, one of which is the species and origins of Yoda.... if I'm wrong I'm sorry am I?

Lucas could have said bollocks to how the EU think about Yodas speices and origin, yet I actually dont see this aspect relevant to the story

Lucas has said he will never reveal Yoda's details

wait a ****ing second... qui-gon learned it from yoda!!!!!!!1

right????

Nope, Yoda learned from QGJ.

yeah the ending sequenses of the movie made that clear

VERY clear in fact. *sigh*

another GL shortcut that kind of ruined it for me

Quite. well, ruined is a big thing.... but he DID promise us after TPM to make it all clear. And he didn't. He's a liar like OB1.

but he DID promise us after TPM to make it all clear.

I think you mean imagination.

no, he imagined a shourt cut so..................

A what?

a short cut, the way he hastily scrambled it together in the end there

Time to wrap things up I guess.

and what about Sifo Dyas and erasing the jedi archive?

Yes, good point. All that is vague now. Why introduce themes like midichlorians, disappearing Jedi, mysterious Jedi ordering clones etc etc when you don't do anything with it.

GL you need to redo ROTS, like right now