Originally posted by unno
Uhh, first of all the movie's rated PG-13, so let's not worry about how 10 or 9 year olds take it. It's not for them.
Funny, because that is exactly who episode 1 and II were targeted for. However, it is pregnancy, who gives a shit. It isn't like showing padme breast feed. I would have preferred her talking about pregnancy than the subliminal speeches about politics.
Re: Was it necessary to mention the issue of pregnancy in SW RotS?
Originally posted by Eddy Urquia
was it necessary for Padme to mention being pregnant to anakin. I found this issue not to be necessary! It was awkward to hear the issue of pregnancy in a Star Wars movie. I don't know, matbe it's just me, but these are the worst moments in the movie. I loved the way Ani and Padme meet in sevrecy in the dark, but to bring up the word "preggers"? I felt it WAS NOT NEEDED! we all know she is preggers, and she could have said it more poetically or literary finese. Padme could have spoken of flowers in bloom, renewal, and spring feelings, but not said, "Ani, I'm pregnant, because you are the most horny jedi ever!! You love to swing your thing, and because you swing your light stick, you..ummm...made me get pregnant. There was a 10 or 9 yr old in front seat of me. I was lost in thought of how he was taking it, Pregnancy? I thought SW was all about music and blasters and old Jedi Masters at the SW cantina. what the hell was that. also, to see Padme in a birth postion with a droid that I guess is programed in delivering and Lamas classes. the droid would say an alien word that I think meany, Breath!1 Breath!! What the freakin hell is happening? I LOVED THE MOVIE, IT'S JUST THESE MOMENTS THAT RUIN PERFECTION!! was it necessary to even speak of it. Showing less would have given it more.
Originally posted by Eddy Urquia
You ignorant participant of the KMC forum....lol! My dear friend, it was i who started this thread, it wa I who allowed the rebels to gain the plans of this battlestation, it was I! My question stands firm as ever!! Did even need to go into this subject at all. We know she is preggers(fans), and if not we(non-fans) can see that she is preggers. Again, did they have to say "pregnent?" in a SW movie. REMEMBER, THIS IS A SW 2005 VIEWING, NOT A 1978 VIEWING. IT IS NOT A PROBLEM TO SPEAK OF THIS IN MODERN TIMES IN A PG 13 MOVIE. However, was it necessary to say it. I'm a writer(majoring in ENG) and in our texts it says "Show me dont tell me!" In lamen's terms(for the iliterate and retarded folk) you dont have to tell us with words'Pregnent" just show us through images of Padme and possibly better wording. Perhaps Padme could have mentioned "flowers are blossoming Anikin, it's a time for renewal." have her speak of spring and new horizons. She could have just said "Ani, i'm having your baby" says padme as she wispers it in his ear as softly as a kiss" See WOW!! it's not that pregnency is shocking, IT JUST DOES NOT SEEM TO BE A STARWARS ISSUE. IT DOES NOT CONNECT WITH ORIGINAL TRILOGY ISSUES 1978 to PREQUEL ISSUES 2005. I hope this clearifies some of your foul thoughts and wicked tongue my old friend. You are very disrespectful as a writer/critique participating in a forum conversation. In fact, you demonstrate your ability and lack of knowledge when you aggressively lash out at forum Headings that you seem a bit uneasy with. you are a sorry participant, in a very joyous and entertaining form of communication.LOL you are a sad person. THIS ROOM HAS BENN< EXORCIZED!!! Can you feel that....huh? Can....you...feel....it!!! BAZING!! Eddy out!!
lol have you heard yourself i think its safe to say that most people would agree that what your saying is stupid and someone saying im pregant is not bad dailog at all you cant justify a good enough reason only saying its too young for children its not even a childrens film for a start. why cant padme tell her beloved husband that he will become a father its one of the great points in the movie that sets the fate for him, padme and luke and leia. he was told so we could see his reactions to it and the fear of losing padme through childbirth
and stupied thread. Go back and see it again without a 9 year old changing how you feel about the movie. Because Anakins fall to the darkside was because of Padma being pregent. The dreams of her dieing made him do anything to save her even fall to the darkside. Which ironic because he ends up killing her.
Re: Was it necessary to mention the issue of pregnancy in SW RotS?
Originally posted by Eddy Urquia
was it necessary for Padme to mention being pregnant to anakin. I found this issue not to be necessary! It was awkward to hear the issue of pregnancy in a Star Wars movie. I don't know, matbe it's just me, but these are the worst moments in the movie. I loved the way Ani and Padme meet in sevrecy in the dark, but to bring up the word "preggers"? I felt it WAS NOT NEEDED! we all know she is preggers, and she could have said it more poetically or literary finese. Padme could have spoken of flowers in bloom, renewal, and spring feelings, but not said, "Ani, I'm pregnant, because you are the most horny jedi ever!! You love to swing your thing, and because you swing your light stick, you..ummm...made me get pregnant. There was a 10 or 9 yr old in front seat of me. I was lost in thought of how he was taking it, Pregnancy? I thought SW was all about music and blasters and old Jedi Masters at the SW cantina. what the hell was that. also, to see Padme in a birth postion with a droid that I guess is programed in delivering and Lamas classes. the droid would say an alien word that I think meany, Breath!1 Breath!! What the freakin hell is happening? I LOVED THE MOVIE, IT'S JUST THESE MOMENTS THAT RUIN PERFECTION!! was it necessary to even speak of it. Showing less would have given it more.
Why are men always bothered by what they don't understand? 🙄
Originally posted by shadow225588
and stupied thread. Go back and see it again without a 9 year old changing how you feel about the movie. Because Anakins fall to the darkside was because of Padma being pregent. The dreams of her dieing made him do anything to save her even fall to the darkside. Which ironic because he ends up killing her.
No, IT WAS NOT PADME PREGNENCY THAT CAUSES ANAKIN TO TURN TO THE DARKSIDE! It was his fear, fear of losing his loved ones. It all began in Ep II he lost his mother and he said "One day...I will be..I will be the most powerful Jedi ever. I will even stop people from dying. Here , is the reason for Anakins FALL to the darkside. Then, his FEAR for loss of Padme, and the child(Ani knows only of one). palpatine place off this FEAR and says he can teach Ani how to CHEAT DEATH. And remember that yoda Ep I said "Fear, is a path to the darkside" it is FEAR that drives anakin to the Darkside, Not because of her being pregnent, its FEAR of losing her and what yoda identifies as possesion.
no, it was NOT padme's fault......
and yea, the pregnancy thing IS kinda necessary to the plot!!!
if you can't handle the "issue of pregnancy," then don't watch movies that deal with that "issue." geez people....do you honestly think the stork brings babies?!? pregnancy is kinda essential to life and plots of movies with newborn babies...
it would be kinda odd if there were suddenly babies and there hadn't been a pregnant Padme. technology in star wars isn't quite that advanced....