Kashyyyk, good or bad?

I wish i could re-edit episodes I, II, and III. I loved the fact that Jar Jar didn't talk. What was up with that qiant flower planet, it was weird.

dont ask questions just go see it.. why would you want to know any of this stuff.. just wait

it's a pity that Lucas gave Binks more screen time than the wookies
during the PT

Kashyyyk? ??? Oh, you mean that five minute scene on that one planet? Kashyyyk was just a minute blurb in the film. which is sad, there could have been alot of emotion and action gained from kashyyyk, but we got about five minutes of screaming wookies, and shit blowin up.

The green clone troopers on Kashyyyk looked cool.

From when Yoda ordered the Wookies to start jumping up and down, the action on the planet lasted FORTY SECONDS>>>> I timed it.

The battle on the planet Kashyyk did not seen very relevant to the actual storyline. There was a battle with wookies with some new design looking imperial scouts, but what was the really point of that battle? All that is said is that "Oh the wookie world is under attack, we can not afford to lose that system" . There were attacks everywhere, so what was so important. maybe perhaps the book explained more which I have not read. Yoda was sent there which kept him busy, and said goodbye to Chewbacca, Yoda will always remember him. I get the feeling that there was no real point, but only to have wookies in the movie. Any comments?

Hmm personally I like Kashykk although it is nothing like in the EU...very nice anyways

dont even read anything on here your ruining the movie for you!

i thought it was pretty good but waay to short

I looked at Kashyyyk as being yet another planet that was in the midst of the war. I liked how it gave Yoda some "field time" of his own...I feel it gave his role as a leader more resonance.

I also though it was pretty cool seeing Scout Troopers in action once again. It wasn't all about seeing Chewbacca.

having the scene that short did send mixed signals, as to what the hell the relevance of that scene was. Of course it was included for fans, but it would have been better off not even being included for how short it was.