Who is the most INSANELY evil (not most powerful) Sith?
Who is the most deranged and badass evildoer? I think Vader might seriously be it. I mean, powers aside, I think that he could intimidate pretty much anybody. But there might be others more angry than he. Darth Bane...
Exar Kun...
These were pretty hardcore guys.
Then there's that one who supposedly got turned into a cyborg, Lord Nyax I think (this isn't from SS but it might not be from George Lucas either...)