Am I the only on who thinks that those scenes are better OUT?
I mean, they were cut out of the movie for a reason.
Why does everybody assume that making the movie longer does it make better?
It's not true, if it messes with the pacing and the storytelling, I'd rather watch it separately on the DVD. I hate those extended scenes, it really doesn't help the movie as a movie, as a carefully crafted film.
IF they put them back on on the DVD, I pray there will be a "normal" version like on LOTR.
And please do not give me any of the "a true StarWars fan wants everything", because there is no such thing.
Sure, it's nice to have those scenes and I can't wait for them on DVD, but putting them back into the movie is not necessarily the best thing to do.
IMO
Originally posted by Pogel
Am I the only on who thinks that those scenes are better OUT?I mean, they were cut out of the movie for a reason.
Why does everybody assume that making the movie longer does it make better?
It's not true, if it messes with the pacing and the storytelling, I'd rather watch it separately on the DVD. I hate those extended scenes, it really doesn't help the movie as a movie, as a carefully crafted film.
IF they put them back on on the DVD, I pray there will be a "normal" version like on LOTR.And please do not give me any of the "a true StarWars fan wants everything", because there is no such thing.
Sure, it's nice to have those scenes and I can't wait for them on DVD, but putting them back into the movie is not necessarily the best thing to do.
IMO
Quite right, though it does depend on the scene, somewhat.
The reason why shak ti was on general grievious ship was he was suppose to kill her and then the duel was suppose to begin.And that scene in the generator room that is suppose to fill up with water it is actually fuel and they had to escape from general grievious I can't wait to see the deleted scenes and one other scene I would like GL to put back in is yoda landing on degobah.