dude AOTC was so much better than ANH! TPM was better than ANH. AOTC was better than TPM. ROTS is the BEST star wars film. ANH is the WORST. people always go on that they "love anh cause it started it all" and "it changed film making for the better". true but what about the actual film. THAT SUCKED!
Honestly, I don't see what everyone likes so much about ROTJ. The whole film just seems a little... off. Han and Leia don't seem like themselves. The ewoks beating the Imperials is just silly. The beginning has no form of action whatsoever. The only good things it has going for it are the space battle (which has now been topped), and the relationships among Luke, Vader, and the Emperor (which I'll admit have been strentghened by ROTS).
Originally posted by The Ones
dude AOTC was so much better than ANH! TPM was better than ANH. AOTC was better than TPM. ROTS is the BEST star wars film. ANH is the WORST. people always go on that they "love anh cause it started it all" and "it changed film making for the better". true but what about the actual film. THAT SUCKED!
dude AOTC was so NOT better the ANH! TPM was NOT better than ANH. AOTC was NOT better than TPM. ROTS is NOT the best star wars film. ANH is NOT the worst. People love ANH because it is a good film. IT DOES NOT SUCK!
Originally posted by Torik_Shai
Honestly, I don't see what everyone likes so much about ROTJ. The whole film just seems a little... off. Han and Leia don't seem like themselves. The ewoks beating the Imperials is just silly. The beginning has no form of action whatsoever. The only good things it has going for it are the space battle (which has now been topped), and the relationships among Luke, Vader, and the Emperor (which I'll admit have been strentghened by ROTS).
I think the space battle in ROTJ is still the best though...
I just watched Empire Strikes Back again today and am still 100% convinced it will forever be my favourite SW film and one of my favourite films of all time. I think it achieves a level of darkness even ROTS doesn't despite what others believe. I know a lot of bad shit happens in ROTS, but ESB takes place when the Empire has been in force for over twenty years! We see Vader murder his own men. We see Vader capture and almost kill BOTH of our heroes! At the end we learn one of the most terrible truths ever! And we are left with barely a glimmer of hope...
go watch it again... it is truly amazing.
For me is better to maintain the categories of the first and second trilogy before making any list from best to worse. ROTS is the best of the new ones and ROTJ for my tastes is a little better than ESB. If i have no remedy and needs to list all movies from best to the worst here is my list
1. ROTS / ROTJ
2. ESB
3. TPM
4. AOTC
5. TPM
6. TNH