EPIII Novel or Movie

Started by Batman3163 pages

EPIII Novel or Movie

Basically I haven't read the book yet but I hear it is WAY better than the movie I was wondering who else felt this, and why

Also what are the key scenes in the book that were either cut from the movie or never written into the script

I enjoyed the audio book a great deal more than the movie. I'm not saying the movie sucked, but the audiobook kept two things intact that the movie was missing, and elements I feel that should have been kept in the movie- these being the seduction of Anakin, and the political climate, especially after the the end of the war.

The seduction of Anakin in far more sinister than portrayed in the movie. Palpatine offers Anakin everything, including his life to end the war and return peace.

Members of the senate, known simply as "The 2000" signed a petition asking the chancellor to return his powers to the senate, and to step down. There were a few key meetings regarding this "2000" that should have been kept in the movie.

Oh yeah, one more thing- The best line in the book that should have been in the movie, but wasn't occurred between Grievous and Obi-Wan:

Grievous: "Unfortunately for you, Kenobi, I have been trained in the Jedi
arts by Count Dooku."

Kenobi: "How unfortunate for you, I trained the man that killed Dooku."

Ultimately, we can debate this forever, but in the end nothing will change. Books are often better than the movie. I would encourage everyone to pick up the book or audio book and give them a try. There is much more to the story than people have seen.

Originally posted by Phyzzx

Grievous: "Unfortunately for you, Kenobi, I have been trained in the Jedi
arts by Count Dooku."

Kenobi: "How unfortunate for you, I trained the man that killed Dooku."

now that line would have been cool

Book was way better and there are too many things to mention Batman. But Phy is right, the seduction of Anakin to the dark side was alot more involved and sinister than what the movie showed. Alot of this could have been recitfied if Lucas had made ROTS a 3 hour movie IMHO.

Hey, JP i tought you were leaving,

JF your on!!!!!!!!

Gav didn't ya got ma PM?

about what? and your on mmy buddie list but it says your offline

Well i ain't
And it was a PM about joining your Trade federation

oh yeah your the droid commander its on my profile sorry i havent PM'ed you alot i mostly talk to JM and Mist

oh yeah your the droid commander its on my profile sorry i havent PM'ed you alot i mostly talk to JM and Mist

oh yeah your the droid commander its on my profile sorry i havent PM'ed you alot i mostly talk to JM and Mist

erm sorry dont know what happened there

Threedouble post man!
Crazy!!!!
And now back on topic

the book was really good

Hahahaha
didn't read the book

you should

Not out in Belgium yet. Next week.

i have 3 hours till i see it

The book was cool but the movie gave life to my imaginations of the book they both rock! 🤘