Superman vs Martian Manhunter

Started by Tassadar12 pages

MM wins, as I recall Superman said in a comic that he couldnt beat Martian Manhunter if they fought

i feel it would be a great fight but manhunter's telepathy and intagabilty along with his comparable stats give him the win

Well going by comics, Superman wins. Everyone views him as champion. When it comes down to whats written down, MM looks better.

50%50%

MM is way underrated

In a properly written fight where J'onn actually used his powers intelligently, or in KMC match, Superman wouldn't win.

In comics, though, Superman has casually taken down the rest of the Justice League, even with the Manhunter there, to say he could win this fight.

looking at the stats you would think MM would win, unless he is still deathly vulnerable to fire. In which case laser vision would kill him.

Still I think Supes is acknowledge as the stronger one, cause if it was the other way around MM would be leading the JLA not supes.

But who knows Supes power has been fluctuating for years. He is challenged or gets owned by opponents he should destroy,, and than he rises to the occasion when really powerful opponents who could potentially kill, show up.

I would say Supes is generally stronger, and has suffered from occasional bad writers. But MM has been misrepresented in a few comics as well.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
50%50%

MM is way underrated

MM is underrated, but Supes takes the majority here.

Originally posted by quanchi112
MM is underrated, but Supes takes the majority here.

for once we agree...

Originally posted by Raoul
for once we agree...
I think I just changed my mind.

😛

uhuh

I don't think J'onn has a viable method of attack without becoming tangible. I don't think mental attacks would work very well against Superman. So without those two options, the only other ability he has over Superman is shape-shifting. Not enough to take down someone who is stronger, faster, more durable and has heat vision when you have a weakness to fire.

Unless someone has a scan of maybe an evil or possessed J'onn who punks Superman with his telepathy, I think Superman handily wins this.

Superman 7/10.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Unless someone has a scan of maybe an evil or possessed J'onn who punks Superman with his telepathy, I think Superman handily wins this.

i see what you did there... awesome

Aha! Couldn't get one past you, Raoul! 🐰

...

😐

...

No, seriously. I honestly have no idea what you're talking about... 🤨

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Aha! Couldn't get one past you, Raoul! 🐰

...

😐

...

No, seriously. I honestly have no idea what you're talking about... 🤨

Trial By Fire?

Superman ftw.

Originally posted by Raoul
Trial By Fire?
I don't really remember Trial By Fire too clearly. Is that when he turns into Fernus? Which in case, didn't he power up when he became Fernus? So any telepathy feats there wouldn't really apply to a non-Fernus current J'onn (before he kicked the bucket anyway), right? Or am I mixing up stories?

Originally posted by Raoul
ok, i'd say superman...

but i think theres already a thread about this in the versus section...

Raoul.
Being a moderator since may 2005.

Superman for the majority. Telepathy would be MM only real advantage and Supes has more feats showing resistance than not.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
I don't really remember Trial By Fire too clearly. Is that when he turns into Fernus? Which in case, didn't he power up when he became Fernus? So any telepathy feats there wouldn't really apply to a non-Fernus current J'onn (before he kicked the bucket anyway), right? Or am I mixing up stories?

no, you've got it. but look at your post before lol...

Originally posted by Philosophía
Raoul.
Being a moderator since may 2005.

yeah, i'm a workaholic...

Supes would win, Martian is good, but he has no stats on Superman. Also heat vision kind of owns.