Poll
3%
3%
3%
12%
61%
9%
9%
Yoda's fight was kick-ass of course, but I actually preferred the fight in ROTJ where Luke fought Vader. It was just so GREAT. For me, at least - maybe I have poor taste. It's just that the build-up was so AWESOME! And then when Vader found out about Luke's twin sister and Luke attacked - oh, that was just perfect.
Yeah - special effects are not the only variable here, are they? Because I'm assuming they are. If not, then you are right, but that goes without saying. No offense meant, Mr. Nefarus, sir.
I was wondering if they were, seeing as the ROTJ fight was not on the list. If they are though, then I'm going to have to change my vote. However, special effects alone seems a little bit shallow, but then again I'm probably just being nitpicky. Sorry, Mr. eleveninches, sir. I didn't mean to sound like I was criticizing your thread.
The maul/obi-wan part of the duel at the end of episode 1 was AWESOME.
Although if you watch some of the japanese samurai movies, which have more realistic fight scenes, you will notice that when experienced swordsmen are fighting, they dont parry each other anywhere near as much as is shown in movie fights.