Originally posted by Fishy
How the hell would Malak loose from Maul? One incredibly powerful Sith Lord, who killed Jedi and Mandelorians for lunch would lose from a guy that couldn't even defeat two? Where one was at the level of a new knight?
Maul is not that bad. Yeah he got killed by Obi-Wan but at least Obi-Wan was totally surprising him "out of combat" (that fight was over). And Maul had not much problems killing Qui-Gon who isn't a lame ass at all. I agree Malak would kill him but not that easily.
Malak will take Dooku and Maul at the same time, they stand no chance besides they suck at working together. Malak would take Maul out using the force alone... Then he would move on to Dooku and he's a lot more powerful then Dooku in the force and lightsaber fights too. Dooku would give him a hard time because he's incredibly good at defending but in the end the combination of the force and more experience with fighting would make Dooku die.
Dooku is hell of a lightsaber duelist because of his form II mastery. Only Yoda could take him. And Malak having more combat expirience than Dooku ? Dooku is 80 years old and spend his entire life with force training and lightsaber combat training and around 10 years with studying of Sith teachings. I would give Malak the chance of a snowball in a supernova against Dooku.
Now about Sidious vs Revan? Hello have you even seen Sidious fight? He is a weak coward that runs away as soon as he gets pushed away he seeks the high ground or needs somebody else to save him. His lightsaber skills are seriously lacking. Revan would not only block all his force attacks easily he would throw them back ten fold. In a lightsaber fights its not even fair to compare. Yeah sure Sidious ate good Jedi for lunch, Revan killed Great Jedi and Sith by the dozens. The most powerful Echani fighter ever, which is saying a lot and who is definitely more powerful then GG who also managed to kill a few good Jedi. He killed Mandalore, who was powerful too.
Well yes. Sidious alone is no match for Revan. But in my oppinion the fight would more be like that:
Dooku vs Malak
Sidious + Maul against Revan.
Dookus defeats Malak. Revan might kill Maul in the same time. Than it's Dooku + Sidious against Revan. And Revan has no chance coming out of that alive. Sorry to say that...