Poll
14%
86%
0%
0%
That's a tough one Vader is strong but Anakin is really agile. I think it would come down to experience and Vader would take him in the end. Actually Anakin could pull off the crazy no stopping attack and catch him off guard like he did to Dooku and maybe beat Vader. That one is up in the air for me.
Originally posted by TraptUnderIce
How about we change it to ROTS Anakin so he at least has a chance. That's who I was thinking of from the start anyways.
Now that is a lot more fair of a fight. Anakin is more powerful, that is fact. But Vader is much more calm and is a hell of a lot smarter. If Vader can hold off Anakin to the point where Anakin is bound to make a mistake, then he can probably win. But since Anakin is a hell of a lot faster, I would say Anakin.
Originally posted by Gryn Jabar
Vader might have been holding back, also, Luke was
A) A better Jedi then Anakin
B) Being seduced by Sidious
C) Better Trained (Yoda, Obi-Wan)
A) I agree a better Jedi, in the essence of being a Jedi. Not when you look at force control or Saber skill
B) Yeah?
C) No... Luke was not better trained then Anakin
ROTJ Luke would smoke AOTC Anakin. He has way better control of his Force powers, is more levelheaded, and has about an equal level of Saber skill. As for training, Yoda and Obi devoted their entire time to training Luke, and Luke had motivation to become stronger. Anakin got simple assignments, always with his master in a time of peace, still padawan while Luke was a Jedi knight. Besides, Obi was a much better teacher when he helped Luke than when he tought Anakin.