Re: Will star wars 4-6 be remade?
Originally posted by darkperson
I think they should.
It would be [B]much better. [/B]
I Personally didn't think the prequel trilogy was all that bad, but I think the OT was the best and shouldn't be remade. When people complain about the saber fights in the OT being too slow, look at it like this. In the Ep4, you had a machine man vs. an old man and neither one of them have dueled in over 20 years! Of course they are going to fight slower. The Luke vs. Vader fights were much better. Now in the PT, the Jedi and the Sith were all given traditional Republic training in dueling, of they will naturally have more of an art to it.
If anything was remade it would be best if it was the PT not the OT I mean look at all the mistakes GL made making the PT. For example in the OT it says Owen Lars is Obi-wans brother but then GL changes the plot so that their not even related! Also so much is wrong with the purge of the Jedi I want to murder GL ( takes pills, gets over rage ) And I prefered Luke versus Vader in ESB than in ROTJ
Re: Will star wars 4-6 be remade?
Originally posted by darkperson
I think they should.
It would be [B]much better. [/B]
They were at their best as the origionals, The origionals focused more on story than Flashy Visual-effects. The first re-make was enough! Of course that wasn't really a remake it was editing an already good movie...
Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
I think they should be remade, and if they are they should have references to Mace Windu and Qui-gon Ginn. The Originals have so many mistakes, such as Yoda was Obi-wan's master. Also the lightsaber fights are not as well done in the originals, Luke should be alot better duelist than he is in Ep6. They need to show them using more force powers also. Also my biggest problem is why in the heck in Ep 4 when Vader has Leia captured why doesnt he try to turn her to the Dark side? And plus with such new technology the special effects will look better then ever, there will be no more puppets. If they remade the movies theyd be a whole lot better and there wouldnt be as many mistakes.
Dude, do you know why Qui-Gon Jinn is not referred to in the Original Trilogy? Because he was an A-F-T-E-R-T-H-O-U-G-H-T. The prequels are inconsistent with the originals, not the other way around! Yoda was Obi-wan's master, there was no Qui-Gon - the only one at fault here is George Lucas for his inconsistency. If anything, the prequels should be remade to fit in with the backstory of the originals.
What's the bet that the person who suggested this crap was a 12/13 year old kid who prefers fancy CG over good acting, and a well-told story?
The lightsaber duels in the OT are superior, for a number of reasons:
a) they fight like they're trying to destroy each other, rather than showcase their moves
b) they serve as symbols of emotional conflict between master and apprentice, friend and friend, hero and villain, father and son.
c) they are used to reveal critical elements of the plot through mid-duel dialogue.
So basically, the difference between an OT duel and a PT duel is that an OT duel actually serves a purpose and furthers the storyline.
Not to mention the fact that in EPII, Yoda flips around like a spastic, and in EPIII, Sidious is a clutz.
Originally posted by theredbaron
The lightsaber duels in the OT are superior, for a number of reasons:a) they fight like they're trying to destroy each other, rather than showcase their moves
b) they serve as symbols of emotional conflict between master and apprentice, friend and friend, hero and villain, father and son.
c) they are used to reveal critical elements of the plot through mid-duel dialogue.So basically, the difference between an OT duel and a PT duel is that an OT duel actually serves a purpose and furthers the storyline.
Not to mention the fact that in EPII, Yoda flips around like a spastic, and in EPIII, Sidious is a clutz.
Thankyou.
This is precisely the reason why I consider even the "crappy" (for the record I'm just saying that because everyone says its crap - I still think its great) duel from ANH to be superior to anything from the PT.
The duels in the OT were for a purpose. They were more dramatic, and in my opinion, more realistic due to the clunkiness of it all.
In my opinion, the OT fights LOOK LIKE FIGHTS. The style of the fighters are also consistent. The PT fights look like elaborate dances. Obi-Wan seems to fight differently in every movie. I don't care what justification the fanboys come up with ("he has different styles" - BAD EXCUSE considerring in Ep III Anakin and Obi-Wan were matches).
Now that it's all over and I've had a couple of months to let the finished product sink in - I really do wish the prequels never existed.
Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
I think they should be remade, and if they are they should have references to Mace Windu and Qui-gon Ginn. The Originals have so many mistakes, such as Yoda was Obi-wan's master. Also the lightsaber fights are not as well done in the originals, Luke should be alot better duelist than he is in Ep6. They need to show them using more force powers also. Also my biggest problem is why in the heck in Ep 4 when Vader has Leia captured why doesnt he try to turn her to the Dark side? And plus with such new technology the special effects will look better then ever, there will be no more puppets. If they remade the movies theyd be a whole lot better and there wouldnt be as many mistakes.
You must've been hit in the head.
1: Why make references to Mace and Qui-gon? Their presance is not needed to continue the story. There is no need. MAYBE a quick glimpse of him on Tatooine when Luke is building his lightsaber, but it adds even more mystery. Mace has no area in the OT.
2: The originals are perfect. The Prequel are those with mistakes.
3: The Saber fights are fine. There is no need for action. It's all about the story. What the hell would be more dramatic to you? Vader and Luke jumping like chimps on Bespin or Vader saying "I am your father".
4: Luke had no training.
5: Vader didn't know Leia was his daughter until ROTJ. Hell, he didn't even know about Luke until ESB. When him and Palps were conversing about "The Son of Anakin Skywalker" Somethin', it's been a while. But Vader felt Luke's emotions and learned about Leia.
6: Puppets were cool. It's easier to have a puppet in a backpack than trying to have a cgi thing moving constantly in sync with a backpack.
Bottom line: The mistakes were in the PT, not the OT. And, for your info. 4, 5, and 6 came FIRST! Just so you know, okay? Okay? Okay? Okay 😄