Ragnos,Sadow,Tuluk, and Freedon vs. EU Luke, mace,obi, and yoda

Originally posted by sasee tiin
.
Anyway, ive heard your arguments like a thousand times before, experience is NOT everything!

Originally posted by sasee tiin
Anyway, ive heard your arguments like a thousand times before, experience is NOT everything!

actually i gotta ask, how is it not? experienced counts for a lot. a more experienced fighter will beat a lesser experienced fighter.

a surgeon who has more experience in surgery is better than a surgeon in training with no experience.

Exactly. By that logic two equally trained US soldiers, one of whom served 2 tours in Iraq, the other never having been to Iraq should have the same survival rate.

ever heard of natural talent?
even though you two practice football (soccer) your entire life, you would most likely never be really good, eventhough you had played something like 1000 matches on a lower level.....
just an example...

natural talent only goes so far, it is what you do with it that counts.

anakin had natural talent, but he didn't not achieve that what he was able to; however, his son did - and look at him, perhaps the strongest jedi there ever was

agree, just wanted to proove that experience doesn't mean everything, people having practiced, and in this case fought, for a different time period could still be equaly good, or powerful.

don't get me wrong i think natural talent is also important as is experience

ragnos vs luke luke
sadow vs mace sadow
tulak vs. yoda tulak
freedon vs obi freedon

luke vs freedon sadow and tulak gets pwned!

Originally posted by Fishy
Sith easily

Sadow will take out Obi and Mace at the same time (Obi with a simple force attack, Mace by charging him)

Tulak will face Yoda this will have to be a lightsaber duel like the one Yoda loves, and he would not beat Tulak with that.

Freedon and Ragnos take out Luke. NJO or not