Originally posted by BackFire
Well there wasn't a definitive stalker in Schindlers as there is in Terminator.Like I said, it's mostly the tone and atmosphere of the movie that makes it horror or not.
Stalker, no. Killer, yes. Hitler, lol.
I dunno if I fully buy what you guys are getting at. The tone and how you react to the film is that of an Action/Adventure, IMO. Atmosphere, perhaps, but only in the creepy stalker aspect. But how can anyone ignore the STORYLINE and CHARACTERS when deciding what genre the movie ultimately belongs in. The Terminator was A ROBOT. He was from THE FUTURE! He was sent to insure the uprising and subsequent ruling for the MACHINES! George Pal's "War of the Worlds" had robots that came to Earth to kill people and make it their new home. Is that Horror? No way, it's classic Sci-Fi which layed the groundwork for films such as this. "This Island Earth"? Exter stalked then stole the U.S. top scientists for his plans to obliterate Earth. Killing off the world? That's sadistic, and sadism is an element of horror, doesn't mean it IS horror though!
Sure, it has an element or two, but they're obsolete when you take into account the big picture, being the storyline and characters. With the mentality you guys are going on, there are MILLIONS of movies that could potentially be labeled "horror" loosely. When you start questioning classic films is when it gets ridiculous, though, especially when they mean so much to their designated, long standing genres.
Hope what I said made a little sense..I think the Sci Fi fan in me kicked the Horror fan in me's ass..