Luke (ROTJ) VS. Maul

Originally posted by Bobafetty
He didn't do anything with the force on TPM, so what? He can use it non the less. The TPM crew where just lazy ass' with crappy 1998 computers.

WTF?

Who in their right mind thinks ROTJ Luke is able to beat Maul, who bested at the very least, two jedi masters?

They all deserve this award...

Maul will beat the movie Luke.

plain and simple maul had superior training and swordsmanship then ROTJ luke easy maul takes it

Originally posted by Emperor Revan
I bet ROTJ Luke would give him a good fight. He owned Vader in about 40 seconds, so Maul might have some trouble beating him.

vader may be the chosen 1 but dude, he can barely even walk

Maul would own ROTJ Luke, he hadn't trained enough or gained enough experience at that point to beat Maul.

Oh, and for all you people out there who seem to believe that Luke beat Vader, you are sadly mistaken. Look at Vader in ROTJ, he is faking.=, it's obvious.

Originally posted by Darth Plagues
If Luke can take Darth Sidious...he could take Maul.

Um...Luke never defeated DE Sidious, he lost when Sidious was dying. Han Solo shot him in the back.
Who fried Luke in the death star?????

And about the force+lightsaber is obvious, it's not since Maul didn't know Qui-Gon's lightsaber was still there. He kicked down Obi's for a reason, he would kick Qui-Gon's if he knew.

Originally posted by Darth Traya
Oh, and for all you people out there who seem to believe that Luke beat Vader, you are sadly mistaken. Look at Vader in ROTJ, he is faking.=, it's obvious.

Very obvious. I can't believe people are so foolish as to think that Luke really won that fight.

^ he did cuz dude he has mechanical limbs its a struggle just for him to move, and he could have killed vader if he wanted to but he held back his anger and didnt want to make the same mistake his father did by choosing anger and going to the path towards the dark side

Luke would win

Originally posted by ssj3gohan007
Luke would win

\fanboy.

Not true

Originally posted by ssj3gohan007
Not true

Look at ROTJ. The fight with Vader just scream fake. Vader pathetically beats away Luke's blows, instead of taking the advantage, which would be the rational thing to do. Then vader quite consciously pretends to slip on the railing and rather feebly blocks Luke's blows.

Your kidding right?

No, go watch ROTJ.

Yup he is obviousley faking.

Luke has not much experience in ROTJ he hasnt trained for a long time...
And Maul has lots of experience.....
Maul would win this but if it was NJO luke, Luke would win

Maul would win this duel. Maul has more experience than Luke

Right...