Originally posted by NightCrawler341
JKR isn't stupid enough to let that slip to a fan. Just because it says Lupin is half blood, doesn't mean he is HBP. Originally it was suppose to be Dean Thomas.... she decided not to make him it... it had something to do with Neville.... what was it again?
I never said Jo said Lupin was the Half-Blood Prince. I just said she said he was half-blood. It is only my personal opinion that he could be the HBP. Anyway, I never saw anything that Jo ever said Dean was the HBP, so why would you think that?
i can't believe none of you have been able to figure this out. especially then jkr said that there are a lot of clues to the plot from cos. the hbp is godric gryffindor. that's what harry and dumbledore are looking at in the ancient pensieve on the us cover. why do you think hbp was cos's working title
Originally posted by amburger1984
Are we positive that the person described as looking like a lion is the half-blood prince, or is it just a description of a new character?
Originally posted by Hermione202
That is a great clue................................The person described looks like a lion........................Godric Griffindor.
Originally posted by amburger1984
I never said Jo said Lupin was the Half-Blood Prince. I just said she said he was half-blood. It is only my personal opinion that he could be the HBP. Anyway, I never saw anything that Jo ever said Dean was the HBP, so why would you think that?
Ok, who here heard that originally, Dean Thomas was suppose to be the HBP? Before when she was making CoS and was calling it HBP, she was going to make Dean Thomas the HBP. But having something to mix up with Neville, she decided it wont be Dean Thomas.
Originally posted by TheSun
Far too obvious. Do you really think JKR would give us that description, knowing that everyone is going to assume immediately that it's a lion-man, hence Godric Gryffindor? It's far more likely to be Ron after a bad Transfiguraiton lesson.
Maybe JK didn't expect anyone to figure that out
Originally posted by TheSun
Yes, he is. I think we all know that. The description doesn't relate to the Half Blood Prince, so what's your point?
I was under the impression that you thought Ron was the Half-Blood Prince because you did not give any explanation. and In case you haven't noticed the title is Who is the Half-Blood Prince
Originally posted by madam pomfrey
I have no idea who the hbp is but i don't think its harry that wud b
2 predictable
I dont think the Half-blood prince is half blooded at all. Or else his name would be Half-blooded prince, half-blood could mean prince of THE half-blooods. Maybe? or im just crazy either one. lol 😛