Are we fooling ourselves...?

Started by The Ones3 pages

it goes:

ROTS
ESB
AOTC
ROTJ
TPM
ANH

and from that the PT was better. but ROTS beats all.

I agree, the puppet Yoda was way cooler than the digital one--call me old fashion.

The puppet Yoda seemed more real. Digital characters seem to move in a premeditated way. The movments seem too fluid and dramatic - not life-like enough. Although in some scenes such as Obi and Yoda in the temple, and Yoda, Obi, Senator Organa in the ship, he seemed a little more natural than during other scenes.

ROTS rulz! It has a lot more emotion.
It's different from ESB in that the outcome is already known - it is the process by which the outcome is reached (ie. Anakin turning to the darkside) that is interesting. It is actually much harder to create a film where the outcome is known, and still generate an emotional and suspenseful response from the audience - which the audience got from ROTS; no arguments there!

Originally posted by The Ones
it goes:

ROTS
ESB
AOTC
ROTJ
TPM
ANH

and from that the PT was better. but ROTS beats all.

In your opinion.

I liked puppet Yoda better myself.

i like the digital one better, it can do so much more such as expression lines and hand movement, that all counts in the end, the puppet seemed a bit stiff..

RoTJ is still my favorite and will always be.

I think we had a rate 'em thread at one point, but for me...

ROTS
ESB
AOTC
ROTJ
ANH
TPM (could care less if I ever see that one again, I'm afraid)

Alright, here it goes:
RoTJ
ESB
RoTS
AoTC
TPM
ANH
Well, there you have it.

My favorites

ROTS
ROTJ
ESB
ANH
AOTC
TPM

Originally posted by Darth Travizzle
RoTJ is still my favorite and will always be.

amen .nothing can beat the happy endig

rots follows cuz it practically has everthig in it .,love,emotion,action etc.................. all except one thing ...............a suprise ending

and while im on the rots topic ,could someone please tell me why vader has to wear the mask.......it never explains why he cant breath without it .............and if he cant breath without it ,how come he was on the table for the opperation screaming instead of gasping for air

i know this hasnt much to do with the topic but i dont want to start a new thread in case i get scolded

Originally posted by dflood
amen .nothing can beat the happy endig

rots follows cuz it practically has everthig in it .,love,emotion,action etc.................. all except one thing ...............a suprise ending

and while im on the rots topic ,could someone please tell me why vader has to wear the mask.......it never explains why he cant breath without it .............and if he cant breath without it ,how come he was on the table for the opperation screaming instead of gasping for air

i know this hasnt much to do with the topic but i dont want to start a new thread in case i get scolded


Good question. I'm really not sure. But I'd like to know.

Screw the movies.

EU FOREVER! 😈