grevious

^George Lucas' fault!!

Originally posted by DarkYoda
Grievous never kills anybody in the movie... and yet he is an evil villain? When we first met Darth Vader, he was force choking people to find the answers he was looking for... that was cool!! Grievous is definitely overrated!

And when we first met Grievous he had defeated a batallion of clone troopers, killed two jedi masters and a paddawan, threw two more jedi masters into unconsciousness and was fighting the fifth and would have won most likely had the arc troopers not saved Ki Adi, Aayla and Shaak Ti (the two unconscious ones).

~wickerman~

Grievous was an overrated Cyborg made from turds who annoyed me with his Empty threats and his irritating perpetual coughing. I shit myself with joy when Kenobi gave him a clean shot to his lungs.

Originally posted by LordSorgo
Grievous was an overrated Cyborg made from turds who annoyed me with his Empty threats and his irritating perpetual coughing. I shit myself with joy when Kenobi gave him a clean shot to his lungs.

You're a sad, yet funny, little man with this post Sorgo.... ❌

~wickerman~

FOR ALL OF YOU THAT THINK THE GENERAL COUGHS BECAUSE OF MACE....

The reason Lucas made Grievous cough was to signify that Grievous was not 100% Droid, not because Windu choked him! Jeez.

Originally posted by LordSorgo
FOR ALL OF YOU THAT THINK THE GENERAL COUGHS BECAUSE OF MACE....

The reason Lucas made Grievous cough was to signify that Grievous was not 100% Droid, not because Windu choked him! Jeez.

I'm sure you have an official source to back that statement up. reference link please 🙂

~wickerman~

Originally posted by LordSorgo
FOR ALL OF YOU THAT THINK THE GENERAL COUGHS BECAUSE OF MACE....

The reason Lucas made Grievous cough was to signify that Grievous was not 100% Droid, not because Windu choked him! Jeez.

Real reason: In a video, Lucas said he thought it would be funny if he coughed all the time. Perhaps this was for the reason you mentioned in your post... to reveal that he wasn't totally a droid. It was after-the-fact that Lucas had the Clone Wars cartoon people animate Mace crushing Grievous' lungs as explanation.

Originally posted by DarkYoda
Real reason: In a video, Lucas said he thought it would be funny if he coughed all the time. Perhaps this was for the reason you mentioned in your post... to reveal that he wasn't totally a droid. It was after-the-fact that Lucas had the Clone Wars cartoon people animate Mace crushing Grievous' lungs as explanation.

So what you're saying is that Lucas wanted Grievous to not be fully droid-ish, and wanted to show this, and also thought it would be funny if he were coughing. And to explain the coughing he did the whole "Mace crushing his chest" thing in the clone wars series? THAT i can understand However simply saying that the explanation given in the series is moot is ignorance.

~wickerman~

Originally posted by Wickerman
So what you're saying is that Lucas wanted Grievous to not be fully droid-ish, and wanted to show this, and also thought it would be funny if he were coughing. And to explain the coughing he did the whole "Mace crushing his chest" thing in the clone wars series? [b]THAT i can understand However simply saying that the explanation given in the series is moot is ignorance.

~wickerman~ [/B]

No, not Ignorance.... This would have sounded better....

So what you're saying is that Lucas wanted Grievous to not be fully droid-ish, and wanted to show this, and also thought it would be funny if he were coughing. And to explain the coughing he did the whole "Mace crushing his chest" thing in the clone wars series? [b]THAT i can understand However simply saying that the explanation given in the series is moot is simply showing that you think that EU is non-canon, which is 100% true![/B]

It is pretty much Moot.

First reason being Grievous doesn't use the damn force in the movie. If GL really wanted to show the Grievous was Force Sensitive, he would have had him use the damn force at least once.

GL says on ET the reason he made Grievous cough, being that he was partially another species, not because Mace choked him!

Originally posted by LordSorgo
No, not Ignorance.... This would have sounded better....

[B]So what you're saying is that Lucas wanted Grievous to not be fully droid-ish, and wanted to show this, and also thought it would be funny if he were coughing. And to explain the coughing he did the whole "Mace crushing his chest" thing in the clone wars series? [b]THAT i can understand However simply saying that the explanation given in the series is moot is simply showing that you think that EU is non-canon, which is 100% true![/B]

It is pretty much Moot.

First reason being Grievous doesn't use the damn force in the movie. If GL really wanted to show the Grievous was Force Sensitive, he would have had him use the damn force at least once.

GL says on ET the reason he made Grievous cough, being that he was partially another species, not because Mace choked him! [/B]

get your facts straight. Mace crushed his chest, he didn't force choke him. I suggest you watch the series for once, instead of just talking like that. And i think maybe you should re-read the last few posts. Yes, Lucas may have made him cough because he wanted him to be less droid-ish, but he supervised the making of the clone wars cartoons and gave that mace thing as an explanation

~wickerman~

He' was cool
And guys come'on he was a general not a soldier

Originally posted by Wickerman
get your facts straight. Mace crushed his chest, he didn't force choke him. I suggest you watch the series for once, instead of just talking like that. And i think maybe you should re-read the last few posts. Yes, Lucas may have made him cough because he wanted him to be less droid-ish, but he supervised the making of the clone wars cartoons and gave that mace thing as an explanation

~wickerman~

I made a mistake, yes he crushed his lungs, but do you ever think GL made a reason for Grievous to cough?

This does NOT change the fact that Grievous coughs so lucas can show he is not 100% droid, it gives it a beginning or an explanation as you mentioned.

yeah, grievious was sick, he would of put up a better fight with Obiwan if he was 100%

lord sorgo you should really look at the animated series .it leads right up to ep3 . it is NOT EU .

i am agreeing with what wickerman is saying . most ppl who say clone wars is eu probably havent even seen it and judge as eu , which of course is just plain ignorance

clone wars explains a lot and leads right up to ep3 .gl says ----not exact quote''since ep2 is the beginning of the war and and ep3 is the end , there was a very fertile ground in between both films to put action in ,.''

hence clone wars did that . one more time -- CLONE WARS IS NOT NOT NOT EU

the only reason grievous was not what everyone expected was cos he was injured. and of course there was a need for him to be in the film how can you wipe out the separatists without killing their military leader

how do u make a poll thing

grevious could not use the force and clone wars was not eu. end of story

Its really Doing my Head in aswell with the Grevious Coughing becos of Mace,

Mace Crushed his Insides in Clone wars then in Episode 3 we see him Coughing and Kinda of Holding his Chest (So we know where the problem is why hes coughing) Anyway, George Lucas Must of Watched Clone wars when Maces crushed Grevious. Then suddenly in the Movie hes Coughing aswell? If George would of Changed somthing he would of not shown us Grevious COUGHING in Clone wars after his chest was crushed.

i think he made him coughing

THEN the makers of the clone wars decided to give a reason, so they did the mace thing.

BUT it is not eu

i dont know if im right about the gl and clone wars makers thing but i am certain it is the reason he is coughing .

Originally posted by dflood
was he over rated

i thought he would have been more powerful coz he was very powerful in clone wars

He wasnt over rated .You jus think dat because he didnt have his chest crushed by mace windu yet.