Solidus Snake
The General
i dunno. id send plastic man for magneto. it worked against doc polaris. whether hes 100 times stronger or a million. plastic man has no metallic parts and can escape any trap. batman would dress up plastic man to look like someone magneto trust and plas, woul knock his ass out.
zatanna, could take all three
supes often beats the weaponsmaster (or whomever he is, the guy from the future taht they kicked around in JLA year 1)
prof X would be the the biggest threat. id use jonn to boom tube him to takron galtos or the phantom zone or something.
atom, could also take all 3 of them. mental powers, physical powers, magic etc dont work normally at the quantum level. id have him take prof X
my other option would be to use flash to hyper accelerat superman, wonderwoman, martian manhunter, and captain marvel to hyperlight speed cause they all move faster than thought (re: jla vs adam strange) and they could kick everyones ass before they knew that an attack was planned.