Was Mace Windu turning to the Dark Side ?

Started by king_arthur3 pages

Was Mace Windu turning to the Dark Side ?

Is it possible that Mace Windu might have turned to the dark side at some point? I mean, in the fight with Palpatine, toward the end, he seems really angry. (Anger is the path to the dark side).

When Anakin tries to talk him out of killing an unarmed man (Something that is against the jedi code of honour and a Jedi master like Windu should follow strictly) Windu says that palpatine is 'too dangerous to be kept alive', which is exactly what Palpatine says when Anakin is about to kill Dooku.

Was Windu perhaps showing hints of the dark side just before he died?

The Jedi are hypocrits.

anger and strong conviction are not one and the same.
mace had a good reason for killing palps, and thought rationally to
come to that decision, as he explains. the only solution was to kill palps
then and there.

someone said about mace windu using the darkside to power Vaapad.

Vaapad is not canon.

EU ALERT! EU ALERT! Run for your lives!

I agree with PVS, he really had no choice, as he said - Palpatine was in control of the courts...

Originally posted by PVS
Vaapad is not canon.

Granted. But Mace Windu looking all pissed off is canon. I saw it as the same thig Luke did when he flipped out on Vader in ROTJ, only more controlled. Sure, Windu was pissed off, but he channeled his anger through the force and used it to his advantage.

Originally posted by PVS
anger and strong conviction are not one and the same.
mace had a good reason for killing palps, and thought rationally to
come to that decision, as he explains. the only solution was to kill palps
then and there.

Exactly. Being determined on something doesn't make you evil. And besides, the jedi acted like judges in some disputes.

Mace Windu was going to do what was right. I mean, three of his best friends were killed right there on the spot. Many other jedi died due to Palpatine aswell (he just realised it). He was angry but I think he was controlling it well.

The Jedi had no control over the Courts. That was all in Palpatine's hands. Mace really did have no choice but to kill Palpatine...but he failed, because he got PWN'D. 🙄

And Mace may have been a tad angry, but he wasn't pissed off enough to take him to the Dark Side; he was just fighting the good battle. You don't have to be emotionless when fighting as a Jedi, you know...

Maybe if he DID turn he would still be alive

The Jedi were confused, they had to take over the senate to secure a peaceful transition.
But, your right, the Jedi were failing....
They only followed to code, which Quigon didn't, which makes him the man.

Wooo...

No, he wasn't turning to the darkside... he WAS too dangerous to be kept alive. And as others have commented, he ruled the courts.

what are you talking about windu was very calm almost a perfect jedi. in his fight with palps he fought cooly and calmly just because he scrunched up his face that doesn't mean anything.

Vaapad takes mace near to the dark side, and that why much members of the order dont even try it, but it doesnt take mace to the dark side

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
The Jedi are hypocrits.

Ditto...plus arrogant, snobs, and dumb (the future is too clouded..bah!)

😛 Mace Windu sucks anyway. He should have died sooner. 💃

YOOOOOOOOOOOO
NOOOOOOOOOOOOO

TAKE THAT BACK! Mace windu doe's not suck!!!

MACE WINDU SUCKS!!! who had a purple lightsaber these days any way?