Is Mace the one to blame for Anakin?

Started by Lord DarqueLand3 pagesPoll

Who is to blame for Anakins betrayal

Is Mace the one to blame for Anakin?

Hey Everyone. This Thread is going to be talking about the Prophecy about Anakin. I personally think it was Mace's fault for Anakin turning to the Dark Side. If he had given more trust to Anakin and sent him instead of Obi-Wan then
1. Sidious would be dead
2. Anakin wouldn't be a Sith.

Also the council should have made Anakin a Jedi Master.

Any comments?

iv ever really thought about it but now i look at it i was mace windus fault and also then mace wouldnt of died so mace killed himself

mace was right to keep anakin out of the palps confontation. it would have played right into palp's hands if mace brought anakin with him. it should have been more than enough for anakin to earn mace's trust, as it is something really hard to earn. who knows, anakin may have been made master for grassing on palps

Mace was hard on Anakin, and it may have helped him turn to the Dark Side. But Mace did not give anybody a special treatment, he is as much to blame as anybody else on the Jedi Council. Anakin knew he would not be accepted in the council, he knew he wasn't going to be a Jedi for much longer. He knew his options and he choose for love over the Jedi. Not just love over Mace, but also over Yoda and Obi Wan... He made his choice, everybody failed in his eyes. And they all did. Mace was just one part in the bigger picture.

In the end his fall is owned mostly to his own arrogance, Padmé's foolishness and change of heart and Palpatine his way of playing it all. Mace may have played a bigger picture then most Jedi, but it was the Jedi Order that made him fall.

Anakin shouldn't have been on the council let alone be given the rank of Jedi Master. I say he shouldn't have become a Jedi Knight for he is to reckless like ATOC with Dooku. If it was any other Jedi, Mace would have killed Sidious. It couldn't have been helped. Anakin was going to do anything to save Padme'.

i think it is jar jar binks fault becuase he is dumb. he is dumb.

This should be in the episode 3 forum base. Or, are you talking about all the movies in general? As Clawed The Bum said it was all Jar-Jar's fault. 😛

Its Padme's fault. He wanted to save her.

Padmé would have gladly sacrifised herself for the Republic. It was Anakin his choice.

why isn't anakin an option on this poll it was his own fault

yes it IS anakins fault he turned

It was Jar Jar... hands down. Jar Jar had to give Palp that one thing where he could make the Clone Army. *nods*

I would blame Sidious. All his plan, after all.

After watching all the movies again...I still say that it was all MACE's fault

Sidious of course.

It was Sidious' manipulation and Anakin's own instability that caused his fall. You can't logically put the whole weight of Anakin's turn on Windu's shoulders. It was all circumstance. And although no single person can be blamed for it, Anakin's fall was due almost in full to Sidious. Not that hard to realize. . .

It is his own fault that he was too weak to contain his own hatred.

In concordance to the Jedi Rules, then Anakin would be made a Master from the very instant he is inducted in it.

Anakin just wasn't a master, he couldn't control himself, getting mad because he didn't recieve this stupid title proves it. He should've praised to Allah that he was allowed in the council.

It was everybody's fault. No one is to blame specifically.