Originally posted by Hermione202In the fourth book , When Harry and Ron were in an arguement ,Hermione dicided to spend most of her time with Harry not ron.She could have easily spent most of the time with ROn but she chose Harry.
Well, we don't necessairly know who she spent more time with, seeing as in this book (most of the time) we see things from only Harry's point of view.
hi guys, well you know what happened, but u know, we gotta have faith and hope, bec. you never know what will happen on book7, I don't have much time, but I wanted to post something JK said about book 6:
"And," she adds in an uncharacteristic moment of hubris, "it will be exciting!" Then she immediately retreats into self-deprecation. "You don't know! You might read six and think, Ah, I won't bother."
She also said that book 7 would be different.
Don't give up hope, guys. HOPE DIES LAST. It ain't over til it's over, right?
Originally posted by KKdave
Exactly!! She was totally happy and all flattered when when harry said she was the best in their year, and was telling harry how desirable he was now and completely ignoring Ron. Then all the sudden, like 1/3 through the book, she does a complete 180 and suddenly Ron is the most important guy in her life? It's Harry who she's been paired up with for the past 5 books, Harry who saves her, and Harry who she has the adventures with. Hello, Hermione is obviously the lead female, where did Ginny come from? All the sudden Ginny is forced into a role of importance? Over Hermione? No, no no no no.... this can't be. I've said it before, but it feels like this book was written in a different order, It doesn't flow with what happened in OOTP (relationship wise).
i do really think there's a love potion going around
Originally posted by hermione7I was here trying to keep everyones hopes up... everyone seemed down so I wanted to help. Its no fun if you guys give up on your ships. No debating then.
just wanna ask why are the other shippers debating here, i have been reading the other pgs. and I see night and others
Originally posted by Saberstylemasta
Well, we don't necessairly know who she spent more time with, seeing as in this book (most of the time) we see things from only Harry's point of view.
Three times? Geez, that would take at least the better part of a day, the lake is damned huge.
And she went to Hogsmeade with Harry, not Ron.
And she decided to run up to the common room after hearing what happened, instead of staying with Ron and comforting him.
Originally posted by RoguePw25
I love H&HR, no doubt about it. Ron is annoying me to bits, so yup H&Hr all the way!
Same, Ron bothers me at times also, not just because of this whole thing in book 6, but i've always thought he was immature and a little annoying. He's the sidekick...not the main character, why is he getting the main girl?
Here's something interesting though; Mugglenet posted a link to an interview that JKR did on the HBP release night with the press. She said something along the lines of the reason that she's killed everyting important to harry (his parents, sirius, dumbledore) is that she thinks its more dramatic and heroic if he has to go it alone and doesn't have so much support. So this could be why she didn't want harry to have hermione... because of the massive support she would give him. But that seems really messed up to me, I feel bad for Harry. He deserves someone like Hermione.
i just wanted ot say that im new here. ok moving on....
hermione IS perfect for harry. i think that harry liking ginny came out of nowhere. i don't think he ever really paid much attention to her. he even forgot she was possesed by voldemort, which is something so important, i doubt anyone could forget.
the trend that j.k rowling has put in the books is the trend of harry and hermione and sometimes ron fighting together. it's pretty hard for me to see why rowling would push aside such a strong character like hermione so harry could get with ginny. i think that ginny will have to deal with hermione.
Hermione and Harry ARE perfect for each other, and it does make me angry that Harry started noticing Ginny when everyone considered her "pretty". It seemed like he just thought she was hot, kinda like the Cho thing. But, you know, the more I've been thinking about it the more I have realized that if there is one thing we should have learned from reading Harry Potter, it's that nothing is ever set in stone. We were sure that Sirius was a killer, that Snape had switched to the good side, and of many other things that turned out to be the opposite. JKR purposely confuses us and puts in plot twists just to mess with us. Thats the new stance I'm taking with this "dating" situation. Nothing is for sure, nothing is set in stone.
Originally posted by KKdave
Same, Ron bothers me at times also, not just because of this whole thing in book 6, but i've always thought he was immature and a little annoying. He's the sidekick...not the main character, why is he getting the main girl?
Here's something interesting though; Mugglenet posted a link to an interview that JKR did on the HBP release night with the press. She said something along the lines of the reason that she's killed everyting important to harry (his parents, sirius, dumbledore) is that she thinks its more dramatic and heroic if he has to go it alone and doesn't have so much support. So this could be why she didn't want harry to have hermione... because of the massive support she would give him. But that seems really messed up to me, I feel bad for Harry. He deserves someone like Hermione.
Same here! I've always thought that he was immature too. Some of the stuff he's done, I've always wondered "How old are you? 5?" The way he goes on .. . . . .I just think that with smart Hermione, I don't want to say that she's better than him. I just don't think that Hermione would go for a guy like Ron. She needs someone with some stability. I don't see why Hermione would go for a guy like Ron. Seems to be like Harry is way better candaite.
Yes, I can say that Harry's pretty much will be the greatest wizard of his age that time. He has strength of character, he feels compassion(ironically courtesy of LV), he is pure of heart. And he has more courage than any single wizard/witch. Augusta Longbottom seems to think so.
"That Harry Potter has more backbone than half the ministry put together!"
He is the main character, I'm not sure why JKR put him with the secondary girl. Sure, Harry saved her life once. But after that, nothing really happened between the two, no clue at all. The act of H/G in the book threw me off. ("What the?!"😉
Yep, I agree 100%. To be honest, Ron is not as good as Hermione, he's not as smart and doesn't seem to be as brave. Harry is in a whole different league. Hermione dating Ron is going down below her level, which.. come on.. in real life a smart girl isn't going to go for someone who is well... below her. The Ron/Hermione thing just doesn't seem realistic to me; it's forced.
Originally posted by KKdave
Yep, I agree 100%. To be honest, Ron is not as good as Hermione, he's not as smart and doesn't seem to be as brave. Harry is in a whole different league. Hermione dating Ron is going down below her level, which.. come on.. in real life a smart girl isn't going to go for someone who is well... below her. The Ron/Hermione thing just doesn't seem realistic to me; it's forced.
i agree
agree too, dont like Ron for mione,
Guys read this theory, gosh portkey really saves me
Another disturbing danger sign of the H/G courting.
Guess where Harry finally wins the fair Ginny! Only in the most horrific chapter of the book, "Sectumsempra"
Now on other posts, I have been writing that Harry was tainted by Snape's book. Hermione was ripped from his side and no longer training him. Where did Harry turn for new training? Snape's nasty little dark magic book. It was Snape's way of tempting Harry and Harry, without Hermione's better judgement, slobbered all over those curses. He quite enjoyed using the levitation spell he saw his father James abuse Snape with in Book 5. Snape could have a chance at a baby dark lord yet!
In this chapter, Harry uses one of Snape's curses on Draco. Draco looked as if he was torn apart and blood flew everywhere. Think about it. A mortal curse. Used by Harry. Without remorse. Even Snape was impressed by this scene. He gives detention to a still unrepenetant Harry. This is the Harry that could not peform the Cruciatus curse on Belletrix?
Harry serves his detention but still unremorseful. Gee who does that remind you of? All he could think about was taking back Snape's book.
After Gryffindor's win, Hermione tries to warn Harry that the book is dark. But Harry ignores her. What does Ginny do? She congratulates Harry on using Sectumsempra. A killing curse When Hermione tries to naysay her and point out that the curse was lethal and that Harry's detention interfered with Quiddich, Dear Ginny snaps at her. What is Ginny's comeback? "Oh, don't start acting as though you understand Quidditch, you'll only embarass yourself"
My fellow Harmonians, Harry had just taken his first major step to becoming a Dark Lord. Hermione tried to save him. Ginny congratulated him.
How does the chapter end? By Harry kissing Ginny. While a roar of triumph was screaming in his chest. Where did we see roars of triumph before? When the connection between LV and Harry was still open in OOTP.
The Sectumsempra is JKR's argument against H/G my friends. Harry needs Hermione. He needs her love, he needs her support and he needs her advice. Without her, he can become Snape. He can become LV. He is capable of using lethal curses without batting an eyelash.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There will be no H/G in Book 7
Harry Malinson for Red House - When you are writing Harry Potter, how often do you find the story taking you somewhere you never expected to go?JK Rowling: It has happened. It happened much more in the earlier books than it happens now, because these days things are sort of becoming tighter and tighter. I have now plotted the books over such a long time that I don't really have much leeway to stray from my plot and once I reach book 7, there has to be no margin because I know exactly what I have to do now and I am going to go ahead and do it. But in the early days things did wander off and sometimes still characters want to go one way and I want them to go another way and sometimes the best thing to do is write that way out of your system and put it to one side and carry on.Hermione often goes wandering.
Interesting that JKR mentioned Hermione "wandering". If she's supposed to be in "OMG Tru Lurve" with Ron, why is she "wandering"?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Harry and Hermione share a love so deep that perhaps they haven't realised it yet, but that time can come and will come in the seventh book, when no Ginny will be around, the only girl around will be Hermione (unless I am missing something and am barking up the wrong tree), so then will be the time when they will realise that it is their destiny to be with each other