Green Lantern vs Silver Surfer

Started by Cosmic Cube8 pages

Originally posted by jrodslam
Parallax wasnt even full powered in the crossover. Kyle could have beat him himself.

You showed 3 scans of GL getting owned by that technique, but ive showed multiple scans of Surfer not absorbing everyones energy. GL isnt based off absorbing ones energies. He uses different techniques like controling, rearanging and redirecting. Just because they dont always do it doesnt mean they cant.

How do you know that Photon isnt on Surfers level of energy manipulation? Assumptions?

Now showing Surfer not absorbing someone's energy proves that he can't? What kind of logic is that?

I think kgkg's asking when have they ever drained someone.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Parallax wasnt even full powered in the crossover. Kyle could have beat him himself.

You showed 3 scans of GL getting owned by that technique, but ive showed multiple scans of Surfer not absorbing everyones energy. GL isnt based off absorbing ones energies. He uses different techniques like controling, rearanging and redirecting. Just because they dont always do it doesnt mean they cant.

How do you know that Photon isnt on Surfers level of energy manipulation? Assumptions?


SS powers has effected entire planets, he has rebuild cities (building etc) , evolved a planet , shielded a planet , used his cosmic powers to heal the planet

That’s why and ya turned peepz to stone, and rocks to gas with no effort

GL often "musters all of his willpower" to do things that Surfer does casually.

Originally posted by kgkg
keep this up and I will retire
😄

Sorry sir... (works faster)

Originally posted by Dizzle
Never said Surfer could fight forever. But since large blasts and such would wear out Hal, but the same blasts would not tire Surfer as much, we can say that Surfer would have either much better stamina or much more power than Hal.

GL can only stop time in an area, the time stop is projected in front of him. Surfer is way the hell too fast to get hit by it.

The ring was trying to save their lives, not absorb their power. It was not powerful enough to save their bodies, so it simply took their souls. Not the same as draining the power cosmic for Silver Surfer.

Also, I'm pretty sure GL constructs are solidified light, which is something Surfer should then be able to absorb. (just cuz he didn't in a crossover doesn't mean he can't)

What large blasts wear out Hal? Can you show that? Wasting minor energies wear out Surfer. You only assume Surfer would have more stamina asn much more power. Wheres the proof of that?

Gl can only stop time in an area? No sir. It was done to the whole planet. Then heroes were teleporteds to him.

Youre right. The ring was trying to save their lives. But because the bodies were too much in number, it took the life energies instead. Surfers life energies would get drained as well. As shown when hes weak, hes as good as dead.

I never said Surfer cant drain the constructs. I was implying that GL would be able to control surfers blasts as well as absorb.

Running into Galactus's barrier wears out Surfer. He's never been drained from full power by anything less.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Now showing Surfer not absorbing someone's energy proves that he can't? What kind of logic is that?

I think kgkg's asking when have they ever drained someone.

Show me wher GL tried to drain someone and failed or control energies and failed.

I dont own every GL comic, but like i said controlling rearanging and redirecting energy is more of a frequent use than absorbing. But they can.

Originally posted by jrodslam
Show me wher GL tried to drain someone and failed or control energies and failed.

I dont own every GL comic, but like i said controlling rearanging and redirecting energy is more of a frequent use than absorbing. But they can.

I can't show you that, because I've never seen it happen. When has GL ever tried to drain someone of their energy?

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
Running into Galactus's barrier wears out Surfer. He's never been drained from full power by anything less.

Really? Well the 2 scans im going to post is way less than Galactus's barrier. And he was drained from that.

1.

Thats all he did and it left him drained.

2.

Originally posted by Cosmic Cube
I can't show you that, because I've never seen it happen. When has GL ever tried to drain someone of their energy?

Against an energy based opponent, all i can give you is the crossover in which he drains both Thanos and Parallax.

Like i said. I dont own all GL comics, but all types of energy in the magnetic spectrum can be controled by all GL's

Originally posted by jrodslam
Thats all he did and it left him drained.

2.


Let’s see

-getting attack by the avengers in last issue
-defeating bunch of monster
-Turing Grey hulk to Green
-Attacking hulk

He was still able to move he was weakened and needed energy, he can heal pretty fast.

Hal was nearly dead while trying to build simple construct and don’t forget the yellow weakness, they can overcome it now but still a weakness

Originally posted by jrodslam
Against an energy based opponent, all i can give you is the crossover in which he drains both Thanos and Parallax.

Like i said. I dont own all GL comics, but all types of energy in the magnetic spectrum can be controled by all GL's


If they haven't done it than you can't say they can.

Crossover absorbed oan energy.

Many times there energy got jacked they couldn’t get it back

Originally posted by kgkg
Let’s see

-getting attack by the avengers in last issue
-defeating bunch of monster
-Turing Grey hulk to Green
-Attacking hulk

He was still able to move he was weakened and needed energy, he can heal pretty fast.

Hal was nearly dead while trying to build simple construct and don’t forget the yellow weakness, they can overcome it now but still a weakness

-Getting attacked by the avengers was days earlier.

-Defeating the monters was hours earlier. PLUS it was Surfer and Strange who together disposed of the rest of the monsters.

-Turning Greg Hulk to green? Strange was doing all the work. As shown Surfer hardly did anything.

Attacking Hulk - All Surfer did was about 3 blasts and a grab of the arm. And that drained him.

Show when Hal was nearly dead when trying to make a "simple construct" And Hal has overcome the yellow weakness on multiple occasions.

Originally posted by kgkg
If they haven't done it than you can't say they can.

Crossover absorbed oan energy.

Many times there energy got jacked they couldn’t get it back

Crossover he absorbed Surfers energy from Parallax as well.

Same could be said about Surfer. Many times he wasnt able to get it back unless he got sleep or rest. GL has to recharge as well. Same thing. Though a GL charge takes about 6 seconds. Surfer was sleep about an hour.

Originally posted by jrodslam
-Getting attacked by the avengers was days earlier.

-Defeating the monters was hours earlier. PLUS it was Surfer and Strange who together disposed of the rest of the monsters.

-Turning Greg Hulk to green? Strange was doing all the work. As shown Surfer hardly did anything.

Attacking Hulk - All Surfer did was about 3 blasts and a grab of the arm. And that drained him.

Show when Hal was nearly dead when trying to make a "simple construct" And Hal has overcome the yellow weakness on multiple occasions.


Where did you get days earlier?

- They still battle the defeated the monsters (who know what they been doing before)
- SS did his share

Like I said he was weakened , I have shown silver surfer get his energy back quickly by absorbing energy around him.

More than what I can say about Gl’s

i posted scans he was trying to make something he failed

has over come , but still a weakness that SS can use

even Polaris jacked Hal's ring , and stole his energy

Originally posted by kgkg
Where did you get days earlier?

- They still battle the defeated the monsters (who know what they been doing before)
- SS did his share

Like I said he was weakened , I have shown silver surfer get his energy back quickly by absorbing energy around him.

More than what I can say about Gl’s

i posted scans he was trying to make something he failed

has over come , but still a weakness that SS can use

- Order #3, Hulk says hes going back to the Citadel(home)

- Order #4, After defeating the monsters, Namor says its the first danger spot they have been to in over a week. The last danger stop was in Order #3

- SS did his share? Hardly.

- You have shown Surfer get his energy back, but he also stated that it "comes back to slowly.".

- GL absorbing energy doesnt power himself up like it does Surfer. Therefore even if he did, it wouldnt give him energy. Hed just absorb and contain it. Only thing that powers GL is the battery.

- You never post a scan where Hal tried to make something and failed. If so post again cause i didnt see it.

Originally posted by kgkg
even Polaris jacked Hal's ring , and stole his energy

And the Kree jacked Surfers energy and kept him hostage.

When absorbing energy from the Earth's environment, his power returns slowly. When near a source of power, like the sun, he recharges in seconds, or less.