Poll
56%
40%
5%
Yes, but his being sooner, could've destroyed everything the fellowship worked for. In *MY* opinion faramir(the book one) would have been the better choice to go, and have borimir left behind to help defend minas tirith, becuase if there places were switched I highly doubt all those men who when to retake osgiliath wouldnt have fallen *IN* Osgiliath.