Re: Re: Re: IS SNAPE vOLDEMORTS BROTHER?
Originally posted by enyafreak
please explain because i havent read it.do you mean dumbledore told Snape to kill him.
so snape isnt a villain?
You have admited you haven't read the book, so I'll let you get away with this question. 😉 If you had read the book, you would know the answer.
Merope Gaunt (Daughter of Marvolo Gaunt) married Tom Riddle who's son is Tom Marvolo Riddle.
Eileen Prince (a witch) married Tobias Snape (a muggle) who's son is Severus Snape who is the Half Blood Prince.
As to Dumbledore... Snape grazed for a moment at Dumbledore. Is it possible through Occulmency that the two communicated. Dumbledore knows that Snape has taken an unbreakable vow with Draco's mother to fulfill Draco's mission is he can't fulfill it, which means Draco and his whole family will be killed by Voldemort. Through Dubledore's death two people's lives are saved, Snapes and Draco's. Dumbledore was already dying. Is it possible Dubledore informed Snape that he was already dying and to do it to protect Snape and the boy????
Time will tell.
Originally posted by Joseph_KerrAs to Dumbledore... Snape grazed for a moment at Dumbledore. Is it possible through Occulmency that the two communicated. Dumbledore knows that Snape has taken an unbreakable vow with Draco's mother to fulfill Draco's mission is he can't fulfill it, which means Draco and his whole family will be killed by Voldemort. Through Dubledore's death two people's lives are saved, Snapes and Draco's. Dumbledore was already dying. Is it possible Dubledore informed Snape that he was already dying and to do it to protect Snape and the boy????
Time will tell.
i liek you thinking, it does make sense becuz we really dont know if dumbledore was pleading with snape to not kill him or kill him becuz all he said was severus please.....so i definitely thnik that occulmency/legimens is a really good theory. there is definitley more to it than just snape killing dumbley becuz he was a DE.
Originally posted by Joseph_KerrYou got your words mixed up. Legimency, not occulmency.
You have admited you haven't read the book, so I'll let you get away with this question. 😉 If you had read the book, you would know the answer.Merope Gaunt (Daughter of Marvolo Gaunt) married Tom Riddle who's son is Tom Marvolo Riddle.
Eileen Prince (a witch) married Tobias Snape (a muggle) who's son is Severus Snape who is the Half Blood Prince.
As to Dumbledore... Snape grazed for a moment at Dumbledore. Is it possible through Occulmency that the two communicated. Dumbledore knows that Snape has taken an unbreakable vow with Draco's mother to fulfill Draco's mission is he can't fulfill it, which means Draco and his whole family will be killed by Voldemort. Through Dubledore's death two people's lives are saved, Snapes and Draco's. Dumbledore was already dying. Is it possible Dubledore informed Snape that he was already dying and to do it to protect Snape and the boy????
Time will tell.
I still think Snape was doing a mercy killing. Dumbledore would have suffered worse at the hands of the other Death Eaters. He definitely didn't seem happy seeing Dumbledore in that scenario and I'm sure he was trying to get out of something like this when he tried insisting on "helping" Draco (should have used legitimancy on him).
As to the thread title in question, they are at least a good 20 to 30 years apart and have no obvious relatons to each other. However, they do have the similarities of being interested in the Dark Arts and being "half blood." (both on their father's side; both mothers are supposedly unattractive)