Exar Kun and Ulic Qel-Droma vs. NJO Luke and Yoda

So if people agree their logic sucks so right now your logic doesn't sound very good.

Originally posted by DarthGenises
So if people agree their logic sucks so right now your logic doesn't sound very good.

Before I retort, could you explain just what it is you're trying to say right here?

You are basically saying agreeing with other people's opinions is bad logic

Strange I did not read that... He just told you to start thinking before yourself, or at all really. And that the opinion of others should not matter, just the facts that they state.

No I'm saying don't rely on other people's work and knowledge to validate your opinions, meaning don't go from thread to thread spouting nonsense and then only standing your ground when other people do all the damn work.

I also notice you totally ignored the fact that I called you out on your haphazard logic regarding "And when has Exar Kun ever made a black hole?". That's called Nonsense. It's like saying Luke can't be a better pilot than Atton or Carth because he has never pilotted the Ebon Hawk, or T3 can never be better then R2-D2 because he hasn't plugged into the computer system of the Death Star.

Come to think of it, I can't think of a time when you said anything logical.

Thats probably because he didn't...

I don't think so, no. He's probably like ten, unsupervised, and a horrible fan of the PT.

Janus just wonderin but y do u hate NJO Luke

I hate luke becuz he is all powerful. I like average jedi. Everyone like revan exar NJo luke, traya, ect.... is not on my top 10 list. But they are still cool.

ya true. i think this would b a really really good fight but i think that u guys r makin exar and ulic out to b way to powerful like it would b a good fight and they would have a chance to win but not a total blowout like most of u r makin it

FYI, I hate NJO Luke with the passion that the pope hates a woman's right to choose.

well i hate alot of people but just cause U hate some1 doesn't mean that they ne worst.
i think yoda and luke that this 1 but after a very long fight where mayb yoda or luke either die or get something cut off

yeah so many koon haters here. He aint all that bad.

Janus hates NJO Luke because of his supernatural powers (in terms of the SW universe itself where every second being is a force user) and because throwing him into a duel makes nearly no sense PAST the events in the NJO series.

How to stop somebody that can destroy thousands of beings of an alien race when another (not that shabby) Jedi master isn't able to kill one of them ? It's just the fact that NJO Luke pretty much overpowers every other Jedi / Sith we know about in force knowledge, force powers and even in lightsaber combat.

On the one handside that is logical because he is the reason why Lucas created the SW universe...but on the other handside it makes no fun to throw him into a versus thread because he'll always win as long as you don't overpower him.

true so y r people sayin that exar can beat him

Well, certain key figures can give him hell and, perhaps in the right time and place, end Skywalker's life... But really, the fanboyism that permeats the NJO series made him a living Force god and it causes hell here, as Nai said.

Originally posted by DarthGenises
NJO Luke beats Exar Kun
Yoda beats Ulic

Its that simple

I don't think Luke can beat Exar Kun.
However, I do believe Yoda can defeat Ulic faster than Kun could kill Luke, so then Kun would be facing two powerful Jedi.

Kun, based on skill and power, almost could win this fight.
But then I remember this is Star Wars, and in the end, the Light side must defeat the Dark side.

Luke and Yoda win.

I would have to say, Ulic would fight against Luke and lose after a long fight. Exar would then kill Yoda pretty fast. Then finish Luke in time to save Ulic.

Not if Luke fought Exar and Yoda went after Ulic. Then, chances are that Yoda will take out Ulic while Exar and Luke duel, and speed up the process of Kun's death.

Not really. Exar was bearly more powerful than Ulic. THe fight had to be stopped by Marka Ragnos, to avoid wasting energy that he wanted used against the Jedi. I think Ulic could take Yoda or atleast standstill against him. Kun would beat Luke though.