The Question [Merged]

Originally posted by Hermione202
EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL EVIL

agreed. Here is a skit to prove it.

HP; SS: Snape: I'm evil! (Harry ron and hermionie notice, but change their minds

HP: CoS: Snape: I'm evil! (nobody notices)

PoA: Snape: I'm eviiiiiill! (nobody notices)

GoF: I'm EEEEVILLLL! (nobody notices)

OotP: I'm the most evilest person around (nobody notices)

1st half of HBP: Snape: I'm Evil
Harry: Did you ever notice that Snape is evil?
Hermione: Ya, but dumbledore trusts him

Spoiler:
2nd half of HBP: I'M EVIL, AND I'LL KILL DUMBLEDORE TO PROVE IT! (Dumbledore dies, Harry cries) Everybody in the book: SNAPE IS EVIL!!!! Snape: Finally They notice

Originally posted by Hermione202
thank you !
Terribly sorry , i'm a horrible artist 😮 😮 :

Snape looks different, did they get a new actor for GoF?

dunno, what makes u think he looks dif?

Read Chapter 2 again.
Snape makes an UNBREAKABLE vow to help Malfoy do what Draco’s been ordered to do. At the end of the book Draco’s doesn’t have what it takes, and now Snape HAS to act pr the vow.
No, I don’t think he’s evil either. Somehow it would be too easy…
Dumbledoore would certainly sacrifice himself for the greater good. And Snape did not engage in battle at Hogwarts. Read through the chapter where Harry is told what happened.
It CAN go either way…
Maybe Snape is who he explain is in chapter two.
Maybe Dumbledoore was not an old fool to trust Snape?

I agree, and I've been trying to make that point in many of different threads.

Naturally I do, but as I have already proven to you, I make mistakes like the next man. In fact, being -- forgive me -- rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger.

-Albus Dumbledore

like how i responded to you in the other thread...it doesn't have to do with Snape. Dumbledore didn't make a mistake with him.

Originally posted by DanZeke25
Naturally I do, but as I have already proven to you, I make mistakes like the next man. In fact, being -- forgive me -- rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger.

-Albus Dumbledore

does that mean you think he is good or that he is Evil ?

most likely evil, the quote is based on DD making mistakes, so he's saying that Dumbledore made a mistake with Snape.

Evil. I think that Dumbledore made a huge mistake. as he said.

"rather cleverer than most men, my mistakes tend to be correspondingly huger."

So Saratn, I was just wondering this:

How do you guys explain the Unbreakable Vow? What was the point of making one? Surely, if he was in the Order and Dumbledore gave him the order to kill him, as you said DD did, he would have followed it out, with or without the Vow. So why did he take it?

Originally posted by Saratn
most likely evil, the quote is based on DD making mistakes, so he's saying that Dumbledore made a mistake with Snape.

does that mean you changed your mind?

Originally posted by Hermione202
does that mean you changed your mind?

No, he was saying that Danzeke thinks Snape is evil.

So nothing would happen to Malfoy. Malfoy is Snapes favorite student, and I am starting to change my mind...slowly.

Originally posted by Saratn
So nothing would happen to Malfoy. Malfoy is Snapes favorite student, and I am starting to change my mind...slowly.

So you're saying that a member of the Order would risk his life for a Death Eater...

Nice theory you got there...

I dont think Draco is really a death eater. He was just forced into this by Voldemort because of Lucious. He didnt want to do it.

But i still hate him anyway.

Originally posted by DanZeke25
I dont think Draco is really a death eater. He was just forced into this by Voldemort because of Lucious. He didnt want to do it.

But i still hate him anyway.

Well, he was a Death Eater in a sense, for he was ordered by Voldemort to kill Dumbledore.

And plus, didn't he have the Dark Mark?

Originally posted by Saratn
So nothing would happen to Malfoy. Malfoy is Snapes favorite student, and I am starting to change my mind...slowly.

Plus, you're saying that Snape is risking his life in order to exchange Dumbledore's--the 'leader' of the Order--for Malfoy's--the enemy.

Snape wouldn't be much of a good guy after all, would he...

Yeah, but still. Draco had to choose, do what Voldemort says, or die.

Originally posted by DanZeke25
Yeah, but still. Draco had to choose, do what Voldemort says, or die.

That is true. If he had a choice, Draco probably wouldn't have become a Death Eater, but now he's in too far. He's one, now, and he'll pobably get killed for failing his mission.