Guys what is Happening to Harrys house????

They could make someone else Secret Keeper now, if that's the case...

Originally posted by Lana
They could make someone else Secret Keeper now, if that's the case...

It wouldn't work, though. If there truly is no Secret Keeper, and Snape is evil, he will have surely told Voldemort by now.

True.

Guess we have to just wait until Book 7 to find this out....

Snape, in my opinion is good, and he didn't tell the Dark Lord about it. Remember Snape couldn't tell of the location to Bella? He didn't offer to show her did he???

He couldn't do that either. He could take her there, most likely, but he couldn't tell her that it was the Order's HQ, because he wasn't the Secret Keeper.

But the point is that he didn't. Why didn't he, that's my question, if he's with the Dark Lord. He would be anxious to show them the location. He didn't tell Bella that he could show them something useful or anything like that.

Originally posted by Saratn
But the point is that he didn't. Why didn't he, that's my question, if he's with the Dark Lord. He would be anxious to show them the location. He didn't tell Bella that he could show them something useful or anything like that.

But they couldn't see it or touch it anyway. The SECRET KEEPER would have to tell them.

But Snape could have takent the plans out and handed them to the Dark Lord, but did he...I think not! Which helps prove that Snape is good, not evil.

Mmhmm

OMG!!! Do people not get the concept of secret-keeper?

ok........SNAPE IS EVIL! ......had to say that

On what grounds is he evil?

Originally posted by misslilsweetie
ok........SNAPE IS EVIL! ......had to say that

Agreed ! SNAPE IS EVIL

But on what grounds is he evil???

Hogwarts grounds.. and outside of those grounds

not what i meant. how is he evil?

well hes a death eater,he sent info to DL which led to many deaths of all ppl from the info he gained..

Yes, but that was before he went to DD.

Originally posted by Saratn
But Snape could have takent the plans out and handed them to the Dark Lord, but did he...I think not! Which helps prove that Snape is good, not evil.

How do you know he didn't?

Bella would have said something in the beginning, about not believing that he had given the Dark Lord the plans or not, something like that.