Snape &Voldermort vs Harry and Dumbledore

I HAVE READ THE BOOK THREE TIMES. HE WAS TRICKING THEM SO HE WOULDN'T BLOW HIS COVER FOR DD.

😐

You are blind, Slughorn! BLIND I TELL YOU! BLIND!

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
HE DID IT BECAUSE DUMBLEDORE TOLD HIM TO.

I disagree ! Snape is evil and i don't think DD told him too. Did you forget the second chapter ? Besides it said in the book DD only believed Snape because he said he was sorry about James and Lily's death . Typical Dumbledore went and believed him . Snape did not turn sides.The reason he couldn't tell where the HQ of the Order was is because he wasn't the SECRET KEEPER . Snape is pure EVIL , at least that s my opinion .

Snape could be covering himself from Bellatrix and Narcissa.

No , He Did an UNBREAKABLE vow. If he breaks it , the sacrifice is Death.

And DD didn't want Snape to die! Snape wanted to help Malfoy because he didn't want to have to do it himself.

Why do you think he took the Unbreakable Vow? To cover up for himself. If he didn't, then he would be suspicious, and they would report him to the Dark Lord. Snape warned Dumbledore about Malfory, and that he took the Unforgivable Vow. How else did Dumbledore know about Malfoy's behavior, before Harry said anything to him.

Originally posted by Hermione202
No , He Did an UNBREAKABLE vow. If he breaks it , the sacrifice is Death.

and if he were truly good and honourable to dumbledore he would of chosen his own life over DDs 😉 proof and selfishness which is evil sin
SNape =evil

For the last time, Snape was ordered by DD to kill him!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nope

All right, let's pretend he did kill Dumbledore, how much could the Ministry do? If he was to be locked away, he could easily break out, I'm surprised Lucious didn't already...

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
You are blind, Slughorn! BLIND I TELL YOU! BLIND!

Originally posted by Saratn
All right, let's pretend he did kill Dumbledore, how much could the Ministry do? If he was to be locked away, he could easily break out, I'm surprised Lucious didn't already...

LoL How do you think Snape would break out of Azkaban? No wand, no animagus form to swim to shore in, hide in, and I would assume they have guards all over the place. So how do you think hed get out?

And I would think Snape and Voldemort wins this. I mean Voldemort can compete with Dumbledore long enough for Snape to come and help him.

Black got out did he not?Can there be spells without the wand, i know theres spells that dont have to be said to work

black was an animagus he turned into a dog and slipped past the dementors coz they can't sense animals that well and they're blind

Remember now, their is no Dementors, so escaping would be a lot easier. And I think the Dark Lord would win, because like I said earlier, Dumbledore's too noble to kill the Dark Lord.

does askaban even have cells???..??

Yes I remember someone saying they had Dementors outside of his cell all the time. High security cell or something. Sorry dont have my POA book with me.

Since Azkaban doesn't have the Dementors then they wouldn't be kept long. Even if they can't break free without their wands, the Death Eaters could rescue them. I doubt Lucious would, according to Bella in the beginning of the book.