Trade federation army VS. the jedi

numbers mean nothing all you need is good tactics and a hell of a lot of force hell they probably have insane force that we dont know about id say the jedi have a chance but the droids concentrated fire would work but they would need to go after the best jedi first

Originally posted by Baston Alveron
Stealth and sudden attacks would lead the jedi to victory. hitting factorys and droid depos

Yes! Yes, thank you! Using superior tactics and hitting key facilities, the jedi could ultimately win a war of attrition. I'd agree with all your estimates about how many droids different kinds of jedi would take out, but that is on open ground. In cities, or forests, or anywhere that the more versatile jedi could take advantage of, many more droids would fall.

DId you see what mace did in the clone wars, lol he took out at least 100,000 maybe less.

But really the jedi here, would have a painful victory, i cant imagine yoda or mace dying.

ANd alos, maybe some jedi specialize in large number, i know you might disagree with me but take PLo Koon, Obi wan, Mace, Yoda.
Yoda mace and PLo overwhelm them with the force, no doubt. And obi wan would defend every blaster and send them all back at the droids. But the only problem would be a few 100 droidekas in front of 10 jedi. OUCH!
Maybe 500 jedi cant get the job done, but if you have high in the thousands, you can assure them a victory.

Obviously there's no logic in trying to argue with you guys, so I'm done here.

Whats that suppose to mean?
You dont even need to start an argument, just write down whoever the hell you think wins. It aint that hard.

This guy wins, duh...

rofl.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
Whats that suppose to mean?
You dont even need to start an argument, just write down whoever the hell you think wins. It aint that hard.

I've already written down whatever the hell I think; you gys don't listen to reason. You think I actually root for the Droids? I think the Jedi are cool and all, but you guys take this across the line. Numbers don't matter? Having 5,000x the number of troops doesn't mean anything?

Nice Janus.

If it's an army of Droidekas with shields the jedi lose.

An army of 6 or 10 jedi could take out at least 100,000 troops. Im mean real good jedi, not younglings.

So a max of 1000 jedi could take out 1mil troops. But is we talking droidekas and those heavy siper walking things. The entire army not just the troops, then of course, jedi would lose.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
An army of 6 or 10 jedi could take out at least 100,000 troops. Im mean real good jedi, not younglings.

So a max of 1000 jedi could take out 1mil troops. But is we talking droidekas and those heavy siper walking things. The entire army not just the troops, then of course, jedi would lose.

HELL . . . . . NO. 6 or 10 Jedi could take out 100,000 droids? Don't think so. The entire Council couldn't do that. I think a thousand Jedi could take out a few hundred thousand droids. But 6? No. The entire Order, ten thousand, could take out a million or so. And that Order includes the children and teens and the guys who aren't worth anything.

So your saying people like Yoda Mace Obi Wan Fisto Anakin Plo Ki Adi Mundi, and 3 other very good jedi could not handle 100k droids?

Oh and it says jedi not episode 3 jedi only so lets take qiu gon jinn light side dooku, Njo luke and some other while were at it.

You are all under estimating younglings, They are not so bad that they would die instantly. Remember in ep 3 the kid killed 3 clones and droids are 1/2 as hard. They could take 1000 if they are lucky

Originally posted by Darth Windu
So if the Jedi took out twenty droids for every of their own that died, the droids would lose 200,000 droids. They have MILLIONS Now, twenty, twenty five, thirty is for the good Jedi. The sucky ones, maybe ten, fifteen. And the REALLY good Jedi, fifty or so. Mace and Yoda would dominate, probably killing hundreds upon hundreds of droids a piece. And Obi's Soresu could probably take a ton with him as well. But just look at Geonosis. Out of two hundred Jedi, what, twelve, thirteen remain? The droids would lose unbelievable numbers, proably near a million, if not more. But they'd win by constant fire, untiring advances, and above all, sheer numbers.

OMFG!?!11 YODA CAN TAKE OIUTTTTTTTTTTT 20000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 DRPODSZ YAY!

There was NEVER EVER a number NEAR two hundred Jedi on Geonosis! Are you on crack? Seriously!

If there were 200,000 droids and 50,000 Jedi, the Jedi would own. Hell, throw Obi, Yoda, Dooku and Maul in there for some blended rapage.

Originally posted by LordSorgo
OMFG!?!11 YODA CAN TAKE OIUTTTTTTTTTTT 20000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 DRPODSZ YAY!

There was NEVER EVER a number NEAR two hundred Jedi on Geonosis! Are you on crack? Seriously!

If there were 200,000 droids and 50,000 Jedi, the Jedi would own. Hell, throw Obi, Yoda, Dooku and Maul in there for some blended rapage.