Originally posted by Darth Martin
I highly doubt that Anakin by ROTS could take Grievous at 100% in a straight up lightsaber duel.
We've been through this before. Anakin beat Dooku because of his form of fighting. Grievous is a machine he will have no problem blocking Anakins Djem So. Grievous took on 9 Jedi and defeated them all AT ONCE! Killing six, severely wounding two, and the only one to come out okay was Ki Adi who was extremely exhausted. He then continued to attack and kill 4 ARC troopers, and escaped a battleship unscathed. He did most of this with only two lightsabers. It should be noted that he can sucessfully wield 5.
Originally posted by Darth Martin
We've been through this before. Anakin beat Dooku because of his form of fighting. Grievous is a machine he will have no problem blocking Anakins Djem So. Grievous took on 9 Jedi and defeated them all AT ONCE! Killing six, severely wounding two, and the only one to come out okay was Ki Adi who was extremely exhausted. He then continued to attack and kill 4 ARC troopers, and escaped a battleship unscathed. He did most of this with only two lightsabers. It should be noted that he can sucessfully wield 5.
I doubt any of those jedi were as good as Anakin. And no Anakin beat him because he was simply better. While it is true that Anakin's form had an advantage over Dooku's, the novel made it clear that all Anakin had to do was "decide" to win and decide to take Dooku's hands. Anakin made Dooku's combat experience,"mastery of swordplay" and his use of the force into a joke. Which was the main reason Anakin won, the form played a role but not to the degree that Anakin just need to decide to win, Anakin could have used any form(that he mastered instead of Djem So) and just "decide" to win.
The only people that I don't see Grievous killing by ROTS is Anakin, Kenobi, Mace, Dooku, Cin Drallig (as dooku stated),Yoda and Sidious.
Originally posted by fascistcrusader
Anakin could take out Boba with ease, leaving him to face grevios one on one. I'm not sure Anakin could take Grevious.
If he gets close to Fett, Fett has fought against other jedi/sith and faired well enough to kill some and stalemate some (and possibly lose but escape death). He even was able to last against Vader and did have a shot to kill him. If Fett can keep his distance than can be a threat to Anakin.(But Anakin can beat him 1 v 1)
Originally posted by Darth HordSure Anakin>Grievous overall but then again do you thionk Anakin could have taken on 9 Jedi and a aqaud of ARC troopers including a gunship?
I doubt any of those jedi were as good as Anakin. And no Anakin beat him because he was simply better. While it is true that Anakin's form had an advantage over Dooku's, the novel made it clear that all Anakin had to do was "decide" to win and decide to take Dooku's hands. Anakin made Dooku's combat experience,"mastery of swordplay" and his use of the force into a joke. Which was the main reason Anakin won, the form played a role but not to the degree that Anakin just need to decide to win, Anakin could have used any form(that he mastered instead of Djem So) and just "decide" to win.The only people that I don't see Grievous killing by ROTS is Anakin, Kenobi, Mace, Dooku, Cin Drallig (as dooku stated),Yoda and Sidious.
Vader had him at his mercy. http://img462.imageshack.us/my.php?image=strongassteelap9.png
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Sure Anakin>Grievous overall but then again do you thionk Anakin could have taken on 9 Jedi and a aqaud of ARC troopers including a gunship?
Possibly, Now I have to ask you if you think Dooku could do the same as Grievous?
and if there is no force powers than I think Anakin would lose since I don't really see him killing fett who could be flying with his jetpack. And abotu the fett vs. vader I do remember( i think) a point where fett had the advantge. But I can't check now because I can't get on the page to look at the comic.
If no force is allowed, then how can anakin beat Boba if he keeps flying around?
I wasn't saying that he could beat them one-on-one without the Force. I suppose I wasn't very clear with that though.
However, for the sake of the question, how is Boba going to defeat Anakin if he keeps flying around. Neither of them are at a particular advantage...I mean, Anakin can deflect blaster shots, and could probably dodge most other things. Even without the Force, he's in pretty good physical condition. Of course, I can't remember Boba's entire arsenal, so he probably has something in there that could waste Anakin.
Originally posted by Darth HordDooku could not pull off the same feat as Grievous but 1on1 Dooku can take Grievous w/ ease actually. Watch CW Vol.2 But thats w/ the force. Anakin could take Grievous with the Force as well. But it will not be a pushover however, because all those jedi that GG fought used force attacks and he DODGED them all.
Possibly, Now I have to ask you if you think Dooku could do the same as Grievous?and if there is no force powers than I think Anakin would lose since I don't really see him killing fett who could be flying with his jetpack. And abotu the fett vs. vader I do remember( i think) a point where fett had the advantge. But I can't check now because I can't get on the page to look at the comic.
Originally posted by Darth Martin
Dooku could not pull off the same feat as Grievous but 1on1 Dooku can take Grievous w/ ease actually. Watch CW Vol.2 But thats w/ the force. Anakin could take Grievous with the Force as well. But it will not be a pushover however, because all those jedi that GG fought used force attacks and he DODGED them all.
Yea, but none were as good as Anakin is.
In this fight, without the use of Force powers, it will be difficult for Anakin, especially because Boba has his jet pack and his armor can withstand blaster fire, so if Anakin deflects Bobas blaster fire back, it will have no affect on Boba and any shots that miss Anakin and hit General Grievous, will have no affect on the General as well. So, i think in this fight, it could go either way, but i would give Boba and the General a small edge, because Anakin has to pay attention to 2 different threats at the same time, without the use of any Force powers.
In short, Boba flays in the air and shots down, while in the same time GG attacks with sabers, Anakin has to divide his concentration at 2 people at the same time.
